Architectural Variations and Ablation Analysis
Ablation experiments evaluated on the English-to-German development set (newstest2013) demonstrated the specific contributions of key Transformer components, holding computational budget constant where appropriate.
Varying the number of attention heads showed that multi-head attention clearly outperforms single-head attention; a single head () achieved 24.9 BLEU, which is 0.9 BLEU lower than the 8-head configuration (25.8 BLEU). However, performance degraded when the number of heads grew excessively large (such as with ). Furthermore, reducing the key dimension degraded translation performance, suggesting that learning compatibility across representations requires adequate dimensionality.
Investigating network capacity showed that larger model parameters (, ) consistently improved performance. Regularization also proved critical: dropping dropout entirely () reduced performance to 24.6 BLEU, demonstrating its necessity in avoiding overfitting. Finally, replacing sinusoidal positional encodings with learned positional embeddings yielded nearly identical development performance (25.7 BLEU vs. 25.8 BLEU).
0
1
Tags
Prep Sessions
Foundational Deep Learning Architectures: Transformers and Residual Networks @ University of Michigan - Ann Arbor
Ch.2 Transformer Training and Evaluation - Foundational Deep Learning Architectures: Transformers and Residual Networks @ University of Michigan - Ann Arbor
Machine Translation and Constituency Parsing Evaluation - Foundational Deep Learning Architectures: Transformers and Residual Networks @ University of Michigan - Ann Arbor
Learn After
According to the ablation experiments on the English-to-German development set, what was the effect of replacing sinusoidal positional encodings with learned positional embeddings?
In the Transformer ablation study on newstest2013, completely removing dropout () decreased translation performance.
What happened to translation performance in the ablation study when the key dimension () was reduced, and what does this finding suggest about representation learning?
Analyze the effect of varying the number of attention heads () on Transformer performance based on the ablation experiments on the English-to-German development set (newstest2013). Detail how single-head attention, the baseline 8-head configuration, and an excessively high head count compare.