Case Study

Based on this scenario, diagnose why the celebrity drug overdose constitutes a history threat to internal validity. How does this event compromise the researchers' ability to evaluate the anti-drug program's effectiveness?

Case context: A research team is evaluating the effectiveness of a new anti-drug education program using a one-group pretest-posttest design. After the baseline pretest is completed, but before the posttest is administered at the end of the program, a highly publicized celebrity drug overdose occurs. At the end of the study, the researchers observe a significant change in the participants' attitudes toward drug use.

Question: Based on this scenario, diagnose why the celebrity drug overdose constitutes a history threat to internal validity. How does this event compromise the researchers' ability to evaluate the anti-drug program's effectiveness?

Sample answer: The celebrity drug overdose constitutes a history threat because it is an extraneous external event that occurred between the pretest and posttest measurements. This event could independently influence the participants' attitudes toward drugs. Consequently, it serves as an alternative explanation for the change in attitudes, making it impossible for the researchers to isolate the effect of the anti-drug program and determine if the program itself caused the attitude shift.

Key points:

  • The celebrity drug overdose is an external event that happened during the study.
  • The event occurred between the pretest and posttest measurements.
  • It could independently influence participants' attitudes toward drugs.
  • It confounds the results by serving as an alternative explanation for the observed changes.

Rubric: The response should demonstrate comprehension by explaining that: 1) the celebrity overdose is an external event occurring during the study period (between pretest and posttest), 2) it could independently affect the dependent variable (participants' attitudes), and 3) it introduces an alternative explanation, preventing the researchers from concluding that the anti-drug program caused the attitude change.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related