According to critics of El Salvador's initiative, bitcoin's price instability makes it impractical as a store of value and as medium of exchange. These shortcomings consequently make it a less-than-ideal solution for solving El Salvador's financial inclusivity problem and encouraging citizens to save their money.

University of Minnesota - Twin Cities

- Lack of popular support
- Exchange rate instability
- Jeopardization of government revenues
- Declining influence of monetary policy
- Financial market integrity

Criticisms of El Salvador's Bitcoin adoption

Gorjon, Sergio. (2021). The Role of Cryptoassets as Legal Tender: The Example of El Salvador. Banco de España. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3944765

The Role of Cryptoassets as Legal Tender: The Example of El Salvador

A survey conducted by the Centre for Citizen Studies at Francisco Gavidia University showed that 24% of the public felt that adopting bitcoin as legal tender was a bad decision, and 53.5% felt that it was a very bad decision. Only 12.9% considered it a good decision, and 6.5% felt that it a very good decision.

Lack of popular support

Exchange rate instability

The International Monetary Fund was concerned that the legal adoption of bitcoin would result in time and resources being wasted in deciding which money to hold for different purposes at different times, rather than putting those funds toward productive activities. It also argued that it could jeopardize the payment of taxes and the effectiveness of fiscal policy in stabilizing the economy.

Jeopardization of government revenues

The International Monetary Fund cautioned that the legal adoption of bitcoin would reduce the efficacy of monetary policy, since El Salvador would essentially be surrendering monetary autonomy to an outside influence. Increased reliance on erratic international capital flows could also cause significant swings in the prices of domestic goods and services, as the causes of fluctuations in the price of bitcoin are much more difficult to determine than those of currencies such as the US Dollar.

Declining influence of monetary policy

The International monetary Fund expressed concerns over the solvency of banks in El Salvador. These banks would be compelled to hold a significant stock of cryptoassets on their balance sheet in order to support, as required by law, business operations and society’s demands. Large fluctuations in the price of bitcoin, or adverse institutional changes, could potentially result in some banks being unable to pay their debts.

Learn Before

Related