Learn Before
Explain why the researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method, referencing the specific requirements of systematic collection and empirical evidence.
Case context: A researcher is interested in whether mindfulness meditation reduces anxiety. To study this, she browses online wellness forums and reads posts from individuals who describe their personal meditation routines and how calm they feel afterward. She summarizes these descriptions and concludes that meditation decreases anxiety.
Question: Explain why the researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method, referencing the specific requirements of systematic collection and empirical evidence.
Sample answer: The researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method because reading online wellness forums does not constitute a formalized process of systematically collecting and evaluating empirical evidence. Instead, she is relying on unsystematic, anecdotal self-reports. To satisfy the definition, she would need a structured methodology that systematically measures participants' anxiety levels and meditation adherence using objective empirical tools.
Key points:
- Unsystematic review of online forums does not constitute a formalized process.
- Self-reported forum anecdotes do not meet the criteria for systematically collected empirical evidence.
- A proper study requires structured, objective measurement of the variables to evaluate the hypothesis.
Rubric: The student must demonstrate comprehension by explaining that browsing forums is not a formalized or systematic way to gather data. The explanation must highlight that the gathered comments are anecdotal rather than systematically collected empirical evidence, preventing a scientific evaluation of the hypothesis.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Which of the following best defines the scientific method?
Match each core component of the scientific method's definition with the description that best explains its specific role in psychological research.
A researcher is investigating whether regular exercise improves memory performance. Arrange the steps below in the order that correctly applies the formalized process of the scientific method to this study.
A researcher evaluates behavioral data using a formalized statistical process but collected the initial observations through informal, unsystematic conversations. This researcher has fulfilled the definition of the scientific method because the evaluation phase was systematic.
You are designing a research protocol to investigate if 'progressive muscle relaxation' reduces 'physiological test anxiety' in college students. To ensure your research framework fulfills the definition of the scientific method, which of the following integrated plans should you construct?
The scientific method is defined as a formalized process of systematically collecting and evaluating empirical evidence in order to test hypotheses, explore ideas, and answer specific research questions.
According to the definition of the scientific method as a formalized process, arrange the phases in the logical order a researcher follows to progress from conceptual exploration to evidence-based conclusions.
A researcher claims their study adheres to the scientific method because they used a formalized protocol to gather large amounts of behavioral data. However, they reached their final conclusions by relying on personal intuition rather than using a formalized process to judge the findings. This approach is judged as methodologically insufficient because the definition of the scientific method requires both the systematic collection and the systematic _____ of empirical evidence.
A research methods instructor presents four flawed study descriptions to illustrate how research can fail to satisfy the definition of the scientific method. Match each flawed scenario to the single component of the scientific method's definition it most directly violates.
A research ethics board reviews a depression-treatment study that used a validated symptom scale, recruited participants through random sampling, and followed a detailed written protocol throughout. However, the investigators admit they examined their results first and only then wrote their 'hypothesis.' Applying the definition of the scientific method, an expert reviewer would conclude that this study violates the requirement to _____, because the formalized process demands that predictions guide evidence collection rather than be constructed after the data are examined.
Based on the course materials, state the definition of the scientific method and list the three primary purposes of this formalized process in research.
Explain why the researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method, referencing the specific requirements of systematic collection and empirical evidence.
Apply the definition of the scientific method to outline a brief research procedure that tests the hypothesis: 'Taking practice quizzes increases final exam scores.' Describe one step to systematically collect empirical evidence and one step to evaluate it.