Learn Before
Case Study

Explain why the researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method, referencing the specific requirements of systematic collection and empirical evidence.

Case context: A researcher is interested in whether mindfulness meditation reduces anxiety. To study this, she browses online wellness forums and reads posts from individuals who describe their personal meditation routines and how calm they feel afterward. She summarizes these descriptions and concludes that meditation decreases anxiety.

Question: Explain why the researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method, referencing the specific requirements of systematic collection and empirical evidence.

Sample answer: The researcher's approach fails to satisfy the definition of the scientific method because reading online wellness forums does not constitute a formalized process of systematically collecting and evaluating empirical evidence. Instead, she is relying on unsystematic, anecdotal self-reports. To satisfy the definition, she would need a structured methodology that systematically measures participants' anxiety levels and meditation adherence using objective empirical tools.

Key points:

  • Unsystematic review of online forums does not constitute a formalized process.
  • Self-reported forum anecdotes do not meet the criteria for systematically collected empirical evidence.
  • A proper study requires structured, objective measurement of the variables to evaluate the hypothesis.

Rubric: The student must demonstrate comprehension by explaining that browsing forums is not a formalized or systematic way to gather data. The explanation must highlight that the gathered comments are anecdotal rather than systematically collected empirical evidence, preventing a scientific evaluation of the hypothesis.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-26

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related