Learn Before
Explain why the student's reasoning is incorrect under the APA Ethics Code. In your answer, address whether students are exempt, whether the code is relevant to non-clinical research, and why relying purely on personal moral principles is insufficient.
Case context: An undergraduate student is planning a social psychology experiment. They argue that because they are only a student conducting a simple classroom experiment (rather than a professional clinical psychologist working with patients), the APA Ethics Code does not apply to them. They plan to rely entirely on their own moral intuition to guide their research decisions.
Question: Explain why the student's reasoning is incorrect under the APA Ethics Code. In your answer, address whether students are exempt, whether the code is relevant to non-clinical research, and why relying purely on personal moral principles is insufficient.
Sample answer: The student's reasoning is incorrect because the APA Ethics Code explicitly applies to both psychologists and their students. Furthermore, the code is highly relevant to psychological research, with Standard setting mandatory requirements for research activities. Finally, relying on personal moral intuition is insufficient because general moral principles can be interpreted differently by different people; the code provides detailed, enforceable guidance to ensure ethical standards are applied consistently.
Key points:
- The APA Ethics Code applies to psychologists and their students.
- Standard establishes mandatory requirements specifically for research and publication.
- General moral principles can be interpreted differently, requiring detailed, enforceable guidance.
Rubric: Grading Rubric: - Identifies that the APA Ethics Code applies to students (1 point). - Comprehends that the code is relevant to research and references Standard (1 point). - Comprehends that individual moral principles are insufficient due to differing interpretations, making enforceable guidelines necessary (1 point).
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Debriefing
Informed Consent
Deception in Research
A researcher is studying the effects of stress on cognitive performance. Participants are told they will be solving a series of difficult puzzles. However, the researcher intentionally provides an unsolvable puzzle and introduces loud, intermittent noises to create a stressful environment. After the allotted time, participants are thanked for their time and dismissed without being told that the puzzle was impossible or that the study's real purpose was to observe their reactions to frustration and stress. Which statement best evaluates the ethical standing of this research design?
Standard 8: Research and Publication
Data Fabrication
Moral Principles of Scientific Research
Dispensing With Informed Consent
Researcher's Ethical Responsibilities
Confidentiality
Forms of Deception in Research
APA Standard 8.02a
Scholarly Integrity
Within the APA's Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct, which standard establishes mandatory requirements for institutional approval, informed consent, the regulation of deception, and animal care in psychological studies?
Based on the requirements of the APA Ethics Code, arrange the following procedures in the sequence they are typically addressed during the research process, from the initial planning stage to the final reporting of results.
Match each requirement of the APA Ethics Code (Standard 8) to the specific researcher action that best demonstrates compliance with it in a psychological study.
The specific standards of the APA Ethics Code (such as those in Standard 8) are designed to be enforceable because general moral principles alone are often interpreted differently by individual researchers, making them insufficient for ensuring mandatory, consistent research conduct.
The APA's Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct applies only to practicing clinical psychologists and does not contain mandatory standards for psychology students or researchers.
A psychological researcher designs a study on implicit bias in social interactions. The study has three components: (1) a computer-based reaction-time task in which the true purpose is concealed from participants, (2) a self-report survey on personal attitudes, and (3) a comparative component using a mouse model to examine the biological basis of social grouping. Which of the following research protocols best satisfies all relevant requirements of APA Ethics Code Standard ?
A researcher argues that the specific requirements of Standard are redundant because general moral principles are sufficient to guide behavior. This perspective is considered inadequate in professional psychology because the APA Ethics Code is designed to provide _____ guidance that ensures consistent and mandatory conduct in areas where abstract morals may be subject to inconsistent individual interpretation.
A new psychology student is learning about the structure and purpose of the APA Ethics Code. Match each feature of the APA Ethics Code to the specific research problem or situation that feature is designed to address.
The APA Ethics Code states in its introduction that 'lack of awareness or misunderstanding of an ethical standard is not itself a _____ to a charge of unethical conduct.' Analyzing this statement reveals that the code is structured so that researchers and students are held accountable for Standard requirements regardless of whether they actively consulted the code before designing their study.
A psychology student is planning a new experiment involving human participants. Evaluate the ethical requirements established by the APA Ethics Code and place the following steps in the order that best reflects sound ethical practice, from the most foundational ethical judgment to the final participant-facing obligation. Consider which ethical priorities must be settled before subsequent steps can be carried out responsibly.
Describe the origin, scope, and purpose of the APA Ethics Code. In your response, recall when it was first published, approximately how many specific ethical standards it contains, who must follow it, and explain why it is needed in addition to general moral principles. Finally, identify the specific Standard that governs research and publication.
Explain why the student's reasoning is incorrect under the APA Ethics Code. In your answer, address whether students are exempt, whether the code is relevant to non-clinical research, and why relying purely on personal moral principles is insufficient.
A research lab is designing a study that involves human participants and animal models. Apply your knowledge of the APA Ethics Code to identify the specific Standard they must consult for enforceable guidance, and list three specific research issues (other than animal care) regulated under that Standard.