Imagine you are designing a new psychological study to address the practical uncertainty parents face regarding children's allowance. Applying the principle that this is an 'empirically testable question,' propose a brief research design (identifying the independent and dependent variables) that could help resolve this uncertainty.
Question: Imagine you are designing a new psychological study to address the practical uncertainty parents face regarding children's allowance. Applying the principle that this is an 'empirically testable question,' propose a brief research design (identifying the independent and dependent variables) that could help resolve this uncertainty.
Sample answer: To address this uncertainty, I would conduct a longitudinal study where the independent variable is whether children receive a weekly allowance (allowance group vs. no-allowance control group) and the dependent variable is their level of financial responsibility measured after one year (e.g., savings behavior or budgeting skills). This design directly tests the empirical question of whether allowance causes financial responsibility.
Key points:
- Apply empirical testability by proposing a concrete research design (e.g., experimental or correlational).
- Identify the independent variable (e.g., receiving a weekly allowance).
- Identify the dependent variable (e.g., children's financial responsibility).
Rubric: The student must propose a research design that applies the concept of empirical testability to the allowance question. The answer must identify the independent variable (receiving or not receiving a weekly allowance) and the dependent variable (financial responsibility or a related behavioral measure).
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
What aspect of scientific thinking is illustrated by the lack of scientific evidence regarding whether a weekly allowance causes children to become financially responsible?
Psychologists use the example of children's allowance to illustrate how scientific thinking handles unknown outcomes. Match each part of this example to the scientific concept it demonstrates.
A researcher is interested in investigating the common belief that a weekly allowance makes children more financially responsible. Arrange the steps below in the correct order to show how a scientist applies a rigorous approach to this unknown relationship.
Within the scientific approach, the example of children's allowance demonstrates that a 'tolerance for uncertainty' is necessary because when a research question is a practical problem for decision-makers, it is no longer considered empirically testable.
A researcher notes that there is currently a lack of scientific evidence to prove that a weekly allowance causes children to become financially responsible. If you were tasked with constructing a new research study to resolve this state of uncertainty, which of the following experimental designs would you propose to determine if a causal relationship exists?
True or False: Even though there is currently a lack of scientific evidence about whether a weekly allowance makes children financially responsible, the question is still considered empirically testable.
A researcher evaluates the popular belief that giving a weekly allowance makes children financially responsible. Upon finding no scientific evidence to support or refute this claim, the researcher concludes that it is more scientifically sound to admit the answer is unknown than to rely on intuition. This professional judgment to prioritize evidence-based accuracy over providing a definitive guess demonstrates the researcher's _____ for uncertainty.
A research team decides to design a study testing whether receiving a weekly allowance causes children to become more financially responsible. Match each element of the planned study to the correct research-methods term.
When a scientist acknowledges that no studies have yet established whether allowances cause financial responsibility, but chooses to design a study rather than defer to popular belief, the scientist is distinguishing between the _____ problem the knowledge gap creates for parents and the scientific opportunity the same gap presents for researchers.
A student is evaluating whether the claim 'giving children a weekly allowance makes them financially responsible' should be accepted as reliable knowledge. Arrange the following steps in the order that best reflects a sound scientific evaluation of this claim.
Based on the concept of 'Tolerance for Uncertainty,' recall and describe the example concerning children's weekly allowance. Specifically, state what the lack of scientific evidence regarding allowance and financial responsibility illustrates, and recall why this situation represents both a practical problem and a scientific opportunity.
Explain how Dr. Aris should use the concept of 'tolerance for uncertainty' to address the parents' anxiety. In your explanation, clarify how she can help parents understand the distinction between their practical decision-making difficulty and the scientific status of this question.
Imagine you are designing a new psychological study to address the practical uncertainty parents face regarding children's allowance. Applying the principle that this is an 'empirically testable question,' propose a brief research design (identifying the independent and dependent variables) that could help resolve this uncertainty.