Example

PCI RR: Conditional Commitment Before Planned Results

PCI Registered Reports’ undated author guide, inspected 2026-11-09, describes Stage 1: researchers check a study’s question and procedures before planned analysis results are known. In-principle acceptance promises a positive editorial assessment, called a recommendation, of the finished report regardless of results, conditional on following approved procedures, evidence-supported conclusions and applicable quality checks set beforehand independently of the hoped-for result—termed outcome-neutral. Stage 2 checks those conditions. Data may already exist, with declared protections against choices biased by prior knowledge; planned-analysis outcomes cannot already be known. Recommended-work reviews become public by Stage 2 acceptance; rejected-work reviews do not. Reviewers may remain unnamed unless an author belongs to PCI RR’s Managing Board (oversight group), when all reviewers must sign. These rules do not demonstrate bias reduction.

0

1

Updated 2026-11-09

Contributors are:

Who are from:

References


Tags

Scientific Oversight of AI-Assisted Research

1Cademy