Learn Before
A community clinic is considering replacing its standard, low-cost depression therapy with a new computerized program. The new program is equally effective as the standard therapy but costs twice as much and requires extensive training for the staff. Apply the concept of clinical significance to determine and justify whether the clinic should adopt this new program.
Question: A community clinic is considering replacing its standard, low-cost depression therapy with a new computerized program. The new program is equally effective as the standard therapy but costs twice as much and requires extensive training for the staff. Apply the concept of clinical significance to determine and justify whether the clinic should adopt this new program.
Sample answer: The clinic should not adopt the new program because it lacks clinical significance. Since the new program is only equally effective, its higher cost and the extra training effort are not justified when compared to the existing, low-cost alternative.
Key points:
- Conclude that the clinic should not adopt the new computerized program.
- State that the new program offers no additional clinical benefit (it is equally effective).
- Explain that the extra cost and staff training effort are not justified compared to the existing alternative.
Rubric: The student must apply the definition of clinical significance to conclude that the clinic should not adopt the new program, justifying this by pointing out that the equal efficacy does not warrant the increased cost and training effort over the existing alternative.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
In psychological research, what does the term "clinical significance" evaluate regarding a treatment or intervention?
A psychological treatment that produces a statistically significant reduction in depression symptoms is automatically considered clinically significant, regardless of the time, effort, and cost required to deliver it.
Match each research scenario with the type of significance or evaluation it best illustrates based on its real-world application.
A clinical research team is evaluating three new interventions for social anxiety disorder. Based on the concept of clinical significance, rank these findings from the 'most likely' to be implemented in community health centers (1) to the 'least likely' to be implemented (3), considering the balance of patient improvement and resource costs.
In clinical settings, which term is used to describe whether the observed positive effect of a psychological treatment is substantial enough to justify its real-world implementation?
To determine the clinical significance of a new intervention for anxiety, a researcher must analyze several components in a logical progression. Arrange the following evaluative steps in the correct order, from the initial verification of an effect to the final judgment of its real-world utility.
If a new counseling technique successfully reduces anxiety but is so expensive and time-consuming that clinics cannot realistically offer it to patients, the technique would be described as lacking clinical significance.
A research team has developed a new school-based program to reduce social anxiety. Match each scenario with the specific factor of clinical significance it addresses.
A clinical research team finds that a new therapy for depression costs $$5,0001%$$ improvement in mood. If the team concludes that this intervention should not be implemented because the minor benefit does not justify the high expense and effort, they are making a judgment about the therapy's _____ significance.
A research team discovers that a new intensive behavioral therapy for phobias is statistically significant, but it requires 50 hours of sessions per month and costs patients $3,000. If the team decides the therapy should not be recommended to the public because the slight reduction in fear does not justify the extreme financial and time commitment, they are concluding that the treatment lacks _____.
Define clinical significance as it is used in psychological research and clinical settings. In your definition, list the specific real-world factors that must be evaluated to determine if a treatment meets this standard.
Based on the concept of clinical significance, explain why a clinic director might choose not to implement this new VR intervention, and explain how the real-world factors from the scenario justify this decision.
A community clinic is considering replacing its standard, low-cost depression therapy with a new computerized program. The new program is equally effective as the standard therapy but costs twice as much and requires extensive training for the staff. Apply the concept of clinical significance to determine and justify whether the clinic should adopt this new program.