Short Answer

A psychologist comparing two memory training programs finds that participants in both groups have a mean score of 1010 on a recall test. However, Program X has a standard deviation of 1.691.69 and Program Y has a standard deviation of 4.304.30. If the psychologist wants to select the training program that produces the most consistent performance among participants, which program should they choose and why?

Question: A psychologist comparing two memory training programs finds that participants in both groups have a mean score of 1010 on a recall test. However, Program X has a standard deviation of 1.691.69 and Program Y has a standard deviation of 4.304.30. If the psychologist wants to select the training program that produces the most consistent performance among participants, which program should they choose and why?

Sample answer: The psychologist should choose Program X. A standard deviation of 1.691.69 indicates that participants' scores are more tightly clustered near the mean of 1010 (differing by about 1.691.69 units on average), which means their performance is more consistent compared to Program Y, which has a higher standard deviation of 4.304.30.

Key points:

  • Selection of Program X as the program producing more consistent performance.
  • Explanation that a lower standard deviation (1.691.69) represents scores closer to the mean.
  • Application of the concept that less spread/variability in scores equates to more consistency.

Rubric: The response must explicitly select Program X and justify this choice by explaining that a lower standard deviation (1.691.69 compared to 4.304.30) represents scores that are more tightly clustered around the mean, thereby reflecting more consistent performance.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related