Google

According to the APA Ethics Code, deception in research is ethically acceptable only if there is no alternative way to answer the research question. Therefore, researchers must proactively identify and minimize all forms of deception in their studies. If a research design incorporates active deception or the withholding of information, researchers must carefully evaluate whether such practices are truly necessary or if they can be replaced with nondeceptive methods.

Minimizing Deception

In a hypothetical study examining if a professor's age affects students' expectations, showing participants photos of the researcher's family members while claiming they are professors constitutes deception. This deception can be entirely eliminated by using a nondeceptive alternative: instructing participants to imagine the pictured individuals are professors and to rate them accordingly.

Example: Minimizing Deception in a Professor Age Study

To prevent participants from altering their behavior and invalidating the results, researchers may temporarily withhold the specific research question until the debriefing session. This mild deception is ethically permissible as long as the researcher fully outlines the study's procedures, risks, and benefits during the informed consent phase, and explicitly informs participants that certain details about the study's design or purpose are being temporarily withheld.

Withholding the Research Question

In a hypothetical study examining whether the age of college professors affects students' expectations of their teaching ability, researchers might consider showing participants photos of their own family members while falsely claiming they are actual professors. This active deception is unnecessary and can be easily eliminated. Instead, researchers can use a nondeceptive alternative by presenting the same photos and simply instructing participants to imagine that the individuals are professors, rating them as if they were.

Learn Before

Related