Learn Before
Analyze Alex's decision and argument. Distinguish between the two types of documents in terms of their intended purposes and formatting requirements, and explain why Alex's instructor for the research methods course would likely penalize this formatting choice.
Case context: A student, Alex, is completing a psychology research methods course and is preparing their final lab report. Alex also recently completed an undergraduate thesis. For the thesis, Alex's advisor allowed them to embed all tables and figures directly in the text to make it easier for the thesis committee to read. Alex decides to use the exact same formatting for their research methods course paper, arguing that both are student papers and therefore both qualify as final manuscripts that permit these readability-enhancing deviations.
Question: Analyze Alex's decision and argument. Distinguish between the two types of documents in terms of their intended purposes and formatting requirements, and explain why Alex's instructor for the research methods course would likely penalize this formatting choice.
Sample answer: Alex's decision is incorrect because it conflates two different types of student formatting expectations. While a thesis is a final manuscript intended to be read in its completed form (permitting embedded tables/figures to improve readability), a research methods course paper is designed to train students in professional publication standards. In research methods courses, students are required to write papers that strictly follow publication formatting guidelines as if they were submitting them to a journal. Therefore, Alex's instructor would penalize the paper for not adhering to the strict publication formatting rules required in the class.
Key points:
- Alex incorrectly assumes all student papers are formatted identically as final manuscripts.
- Undergraduate theses allow formatting deviations (like embedding tables/figures) to improve readability.
- Research methods course papers must simulate manuscripts prepared for publication submission, requiring strict adherence to guidelines.
- The instructor would penalize Alex because the pedagogical goal of the course is to practice strict publication formatting.
Rubric: The response must analyze Alex's formatting choice by highlighting the distinction between the formatting rules of a standard final manuscript (like a thesis) and a research methods course paper. It must identify that a thesis allows readability-enhancing deviations (embedded tables) because it is not for publication, whereas a research methods paper requires strict adherence to publication submission guidelines as a learning exercise.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Which of the following best describes the defining characteristic of a final manuscript?
Because final manuscripts, such as theses and dissertations, are not intended for professional publication, authors may sometimes deviate from strict formatting rules by embedding tables directly within the text to enhance readability.
Match each document type or category with the formatting expectation that best applies to it within a psychology research context.
In a psychology program, the formatting of a research document often depends on its intended audience and purpose. Arrange the following document types in order of their typical allowance for formatting deviations from strict publication standards (from the most flexibility allowed to the least flexibility allowed/most strict).
A final manuscript is a document prepared by an author in its completed form with the explicit intention of submitting it for publication in a professional journal.
Although final manuscripts such as theses and dissertations may embed figures and tables within the text to improve readability, students in a research methods course are typically required to follow strict _____ formatting guidelines, as if their paper were being submitted to a professional journal.
To justify an instructor's decision to penalize a student for embedding tables in a thesis—even though a thesis is technically a 'final manuscript'—one must evaluate the paper based on the requirement for strict _____ formatting rather than the flexible formatting allowed for internal readability.
Imagine you are writing two different documents: a senior honors thesis that will be archived in your university's library and a lab report for your Research Methods in Psychology course. Explain how you would apply APA formatting guidelines to the tables and figures in each document, and justify why their formatting requirements differ based on the purpose of each document.
Analyze Alex's decision and argument. Distinguish between the two types of documents in terms of their intended purposes and formatting requirements, and explain why Alex's instructor for the research methods course would likely penalize this formatting choice.
Evaluate the educational value of requiring students in a research methods course to follow strict publication formatting guidelines (such as placing tables and figures at the end of the manuscript) rather than allowing the reader-friendly deviations permitted in a standard final manuscript.