Learn Before
Based on your understanding of the research literature, diagnose which of these two sources qualifies as a professional journal and explain why, using the defining characteristics of professional journals.
Case context: A psychology student, Maya, is tasked with gathering resources for a literature review on memory. She finds a psychology magazine published weekly that summarizes recent news, and she finds a quarterly periodical that features rigorous, double-blind peer-reviewed empirical research reports and review articles.
Question: Based on your understanding of the research literature, diagnose which of these two sources qualifies as a professional journal and explain why, using the defining characteristics of professional journals.
Sample answer: The quarterly periodical qualifies as a professional journal. This is because professional journals are defined as periodicals that are typically issued on a monthly or quarterly basis in individual volumes and publish original research. Crucially, they undergo a rigorous peer review process to ensure quality and primarily feature empirical research reports and review articles, which exactly matches the description of the second source. The weekly news magazine does not fit this definition.
Key points:
- Identifies the quarterly periodical as the professional journal.
- Notes the publication frequency (monthly or quarterly) aligns with the definition of a professional journal.
- Explains that the presence of a rigorous double-blind peer review process is a defining feature.
- Recognizes that featuring empirical research reports and review articles characterizes professional journals.
Rubric: Award full credit if the student correctly identifies the quarterly periodical as the professional journal and justifies the decision by citing its publication frequency, its rigorous peer-review process, and its inclusion of empirical research reports and review articles.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Scholarly Articles
Review Articles
Double-Blind Peer Review
Empirical Research Report
Review Article
In the context of psychological research literature, what key process distinguishes professional journals as a reliable source of information compared to general periodicals?
Match each term related to professional journals with its correct characteristic or role in psychological research.
Look at the provided figure (Figure 2.6) showing sources for finding a research topic. If a student selects 'Journal Articles' from a periodical that is published in quarterly volumes and requires a rigorous peer-review process by independent experts, they have correctly chosen a professional journal as their source.
Analyze the publication process of a professional journal. Sequence the following steps to show how a researcher’s work is vetted and organized to become a reliable part of the research literature.
Suppose you are tasked with developing the organizational blueprint for a new professional journal titled 'Psychological Science Quarterly'. Which set of operational standards must you integrate into your design to ensure the publication serves as a primary source of research literature?
Professional journals are periodicals that are typically issued on a daily or weekly basis to publish new research findings.
When evaluating the scientific authority of different information resources, a researcher would judge a professional journal as more credible than a general magazine because the journal requires every article to successfully pass a(n) _____ process to ensure the work meets rigorous standards for quality and methodology.
Match each researcher's specific academic objective with the corresponding component or product of a professional journal that fulfills it.
An editor analyzing why a manuscript was rejected from a professional journal determines that the paper did not satisfy the standards of the independent experts who evaluated it, highlighting that the primary mechanism ensuring quality in these periodicals is the rigorous _____ process.
A psychology department is evaluating the credibility of a study before citing it. Sequence the milestones of a study's quality control process, from its initial compilation to its final public release in the scientific literature.
Define what a professional journal is and list its defining characteristics, including how it is typically issued, its primary role in the research literature, the quality control process it undergoes, and the two basic types of articles it mostly features.
Based on your understanding of the research literature, diagnose which of these two sources qualifies as a professional journal and explain why, using the defining characteristics of professional journals.
A researcher wants to publish a manuscript that summarizes the overall findings of the last fifty years of research on childhood cognitive development, rather than presenting a brand new experiment. What specific type of article found in a professional journal should the researcher submit?