The diagram of Karim's indifference map is plotted with daily free time on the horizontal axis and consumption on the vertical axis. The map displays three distinct, convex, downward-sloping indifference curves that were generated by setting specific utility levels in Karim's utility function. The uppermost curve, which represents the highest level of satisfaction, corresponds to a utility level ($u_0$) of 40,100. The two curves below it represent progressively lower utility levels of 21,000 and 8,000, respectively.

Karim's Indifference Map

In a consumption-leisure model, the utility of different bundles can be compared based on their position relative to an indifference curve. For example, consider a diagram with axes for daily free time and consumption. A point A, characterized by low free time and high consumption, is situated on a specific indifference curve. If another point, B, is located such that the indifference curve passing through A lies below it, then bundle B is considered superior to bundle A. This positioning signifies that B is on a higher indifference curve and thus provides greater utility, even if its composition of goods (e.g., high free time and low consumption) is different from A's.

Comparing Utility of Points On and Off an Indifference Curve

This diagram illustrates an individual's preferences regarding the trade-off between daily free time and academic performance. The horizontal axis measures hours of free time per day, ranging from 0 to 24. The vertical axis measures the final grade, ranging from 0 to 600. Coordinates on this graph are represented as (hours of free time, final grade). The map displays three indifference curves, which are characterized as being downward-sloping, convex, and nearly parallel to each other, representing different levels of satisfaction or utility.

Indifference Map for Free Time vs. Final Grade

A key limitation of using an indifference map to represent preferences is that it offers an incomplete ranking. While it allows for comparing bundles that lie on different depicted curves, it does not enable a direct comparison of two bundles that are located in the area between two existing indifference curves. Without drawing an additional curve through one of the points, it is not possible to definitively state which bundle is preferred.

Limitation of Indifference Maps: Incomplete Preference Ranking

An indifference map is a graphical tool that visualizes a person's preferences by displaying a set of indifference curves. While the map shows which combinations of goods yield higher or lower utility by their position on different curves, it provides an incomplete picture of overall preferences. This is because it may not be possible to determine the preferred bundle between two points that lie in the space between the drawn indifference curves.

Google

An indifference curve is a graphical representation connecting all combinations ('bundles') of goods that provide an individual with an equal level of utility or satisfaction. Since all points on the curve yield the same satisfaction, the individual is indifferent between them. A key property of indifference maps is that higher curves (those further from the origin) represent greater levels of utility. For instance, in Angela's model, bundles on indifference curves like IC4 or IC5 are preferred to any bundle on a lower curve like IC3.

Indifference Curve

To cite the ebook, use The CORE Econ Team 2023 The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics Open access e-text https://core-econ.org/the-economy/.

To cite a unit, use The CORE Econ Team 2023 The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics Open access e-text https://core-econ.org/the-economy/ Unit [unit number] (url).

CORE Econ - The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics

A systematic method for constructing an indifference curve involves a sequential questioning process to identify bundles of goods that yield the same utility. Starting with an initial bundle, like point A (15 hours of free time, €540), the individual is asked how much of one good (consumption) they would trade for an additional unit of the other (free time). For instance, if Karim is willing to sacrifice €94 for one extra hour of free time, it establishes that he is indifferent between point A and point E (16 hours, €446). This process is repeated for subsequent points (E to F, F to G, etc.) to map out a series of equally satisfying combinations. These points are then plotted and connected to form the curve.

Activity: Constructing an Indifference Curve

The characteristic shape of an indifference curve is generally expected to be both downward-sloping and convex to the origin. The downward slope is a result of the 'more is better' assumption. The convexity, which causes the curve to become flatter as one moves to the right, is a direct result of diminishing marginal rate of substitution (MRS). This principle stems from the plausible assumption that the more of one good an individual possesses, the more willing they are to trade it for the other good. Consequently, the MRS (the absolute value of the slope) decreases as the quantity of the good on the horizontal axis increases. If an indifference curve is expressed as an equation with one good as a function of the other, it forms a convex function.

Shape of an Indifference Curve

The Indifference Map

Indifference curves are graphical representations based on a set of standard assumptions regarding an individual's preferences between two goods. These assumptions are what determine the characteristic shape and properties of the curves.

Assumptions about Preferences in Indifference Curve Analysis

Calculus provides multiple methods for analyzing indifference curves. One approach is to rearrange the indifference curve equation to express one good as an explicit function of the other, and then differentiate to find the slope. An alternative and often more general technique is implicit differentiation. This method is applied directly to the utility function and considers how one good (e.g., consumption) must change in response to a small change in the other (e.g., free time) to keep the utility level constant. For a more rigorous mathematical treatment of these techniques—including the use of derivatives to determine properties like quasi-linearity, calculate the MRS, and apply implicit differentiation—readers can consult Sections 14.1, 15.1, 17.1, and 17.3 of 'Mathematics for Economists: An Introductory Textbook' by Malcolm Pemberton and Nicholas Rau (4th ed., 2015 or 5th ed., 2023).

Calculus-Based Methods for Analyzing Indifference Curves

A core principle for standard indifference curves is that individuals prefer having more of a good to less, an assumption known as non-satiation. Consequently, any bundle of goods located above and to the right of an indifference curve is strictly preferred to any bundle on the curve itself. This preference exists because the new bundle contains a greater quantity of both goods, resulting in a higher level of utility.

The 'More is Better' Principle for Indifference Curves

A key similarity between the preferences of Angela (for grain and free time) and those of Karim in Unit 3 is that both are modeled as being convex. For both individuals, this property is represented by indifference curves that slope downward and become progressively flatter as one moves to the right, signifying a diminishing marginal rate of substitution.

Learn Before

Related

Learn After