Events like the shutdown of an entire firm or large-scale layoffs can be treated as natural experiments to analyze the costs of job loss. These scenarios allow researchers to compare the earnings of the same group of employees before and after becoming unemployed. This method is particularly effective because job loss is not selective based on individual performance—for example, when a factory relocates, all workers are affected. This bypasses the selection bias that occurs when comparing the general populations of employed and unemployed people.

Using Firm Closures as Natural Experiments to Estimate Job Loss Costs

A study by economist Edward Lazear and his co-authors provides a practical example of the incentive power of employment rents, often highlighted as a case study for how economists learn from empirical facts. Lazear, a former economic adviser to US President George W. Bush, and his team researched a single technology services firm across 12 US states from 2006 to 2010. The study aimed to understand how the 2008 global financial crisis affected the firm's labor productivity and the behavior of its employees and managers during this severe recession. The findings from this research are frequently used as a basis for analyzing related economic questions.

Lazear and Co-authors' Study on Employment Rents and Productivity During a Recession

The receipt of an unforeseen inheritance can be utilized as a natural experiment to examine the effects of credit constraints. Since the inheritance is an unexpected event, it is considered 'as good as randomly assigned,' which allows for the study of its impact on individuals who might be limited by their access to credit. For instance, studies indicate that receiving an inheritance substantially increases the likelihood of an individual starting a new business or expanding an existing one, which implies that a lack of capital was a significant prior constraint. [2, 4, 9, 10]

Unexpected Inheritance as a Natural Experiment for Credit Constraints

Another way to identify credit-constrained individuals through a natural experiment is by observing their behavior following an automatic increase in their credit card's borrowing limit. Evidence from a US study shows that when people's credit limits are raised, allowing them to borrow more, they often choose to do so. This increase in borrowing suggests that their previous spending was restricted by their access to credit.

Credit Card Limit Increases as a Natural Experiment for Credit Constraints

A natural experiment is an empirical research method that analyzes the impact of a condition by comparing groups that are affected differently by an external, random event. These events, such as changes in laws, policies, or weather, create a naturally occurring experimental setup. This approach provides valuable insights, but only if the differing conditions were not a deliberate response to other factors that could also influence the outcome.

Google

To determine the employment rent, or net cost of job loss, one must evaluate and compare all the benefits and costs of a job with the alternative of being unemployed. However, this estimation process is not simple. The complexity stems largely from the need to account for significant but hard-to-measure factors, such as the psychological and social costs associated with unemployment, which makes a precise calculation challenging.

Calculating Employment Rent

To cite the ebook, use The CORE Econ Team 2023 The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics Open access e-text https://core-econ.org/the-economy/.

To cite a unit, use The CORE Econ Team 2023 The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics Open access e-text https://core-econ.org/the-economy/ Unit [unit number] (url).

CORE Econ - The Economy 2.0: Microeconomics

To determine an employee's employment rent, one must analyze how the employee evaluates the key aspects of their job. This evaluation, as applied in Maria's case, is the foundational step in quantifying the economic value she derives from her employment compared to her next best alternative.

Calculating Employment Rent via Job Evaluation

It is often more practical to express the value of employment options, and the resulting employment rents, in terms of hourly or weekly amounts. This approach simplifies calculations and comparisons, as opposed to assessing the total value over a prolonged period like several years.

Convenience of Calculating Employment Rent in Hourly or Weekly Terms

The value of a worker's reservation option of unemployment is not solely based on the direct utility received while jobless (e.g., $6 per hour for Maria). It must also incorporate the value of the opportunity to search for and potentially secure a new job. Therefore, a comprehensive evaluation considers both the immediate benefits of unemployment and the prospective gains from future employment opportunities, averaged over the relevant time period.

Components for Valuing the Reservation Option of Unemployment

A useful method for evaluating a complex reservation option, such as being unemployed while job searching, is to calculate its average value over a specific planning horizon. This is achieved by summing the expected utilities from different periods (e.g., time unemployed and time employed in a new job) and then dividing by the total duration of the planning period. This calculation transforms the complex option into an equivalent, simpler hypothetical job offering a specific net utility, which represents the reservation wage. An individual would be indifferent between this hypothetical job and their actual reservation option.

Simplifying the Reservation Option via an Equivalent Hypothetical Job

In line with the nature of all economic models, the framework used to represent Maria's employment rent is a simplification. This model intentionally excludes certain factors that could be significant in reality, in order to create a more focused and manageable analysis.

The Simplified Nature of the Employment Rent Model

A direct comparison of the economic situations between employed and unemployed individuals is problematic. The two groups are not interchangeable, as the unemployed population typically has different skills and work experience. As a result, if the currently unemployed were to find jobs, their average earnings would likely be less than the average for those who are already employed.

Learn Before

Related

Learn After