Learn Before
Diagnose the potential ethical issues in Dr. Smith's recruitment strategy and justify why these practices violate ethical standards regarding research inducements.
Case context: Dr. Smith is recruiting participants for a demanding longitudinal study on sleep deprivation. To encourage participation, she offers $5,000 to each participant who completes the month-long study. Additionally, she offers free psychiatric evaluations, but does not provide details on what the evaluations entail or if there are any potential drawbacks to receiving them.
Question: Diagnose the potential ethical issues in Dr. Smith's recruitment strategy and justify why these practices violate ethical standards regarding research inducements.
Sample answer: Dr. Smith's offer of $5,000 may be considered an excessive financial inducement, which is unethical because it can become coercive by unduly influencing potential participants to ignore the study's risks. Furthermore, by not detailing what the psychiatric evaluations entail or their potential drawbacks, she fails to clearly explain the nature, risks, obligations, and limitations of the professional services offered as an incentive.
Key points:
- Identify the $5,000 as a potentially excessive financial inducement
- Explain that excessive inducements can become coercive
- Identify the failure to explain the nature of the psychiatric evaluations
- Note the failure to disclose the risks, obligations, and limitations of the professional services
Rubric: A strong response will identify both the potential coercion of the large financial reward and the failure to disclose the nature and risks of the professional services.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
When recruiting participants for a research study, why must psychologists make reasonable efforts to avoid offering excessive or inappropriate financial inducements?
Match each term related to ethical participation incentives with the description that best captures its meaning in psychological research.
A researcher is recruiting participants for a study on grief and offers free, long-term bereavement counseling as an incentive. According to ethical standards, as long as the counseling is not so valuable that it becomes coercive, the researcher has no further obligation to explain the details of the service to potential participants.
A researcher is offering a $300 cash incentive for a 45-minute study involving a high-stress memory task, specifically targeting participants from a local shelter for the unhoused. Arrange the following steps in the correct logical order for an ethical analysis to determine if this inducement is coercive.
You are designing the recruitment protocol for a longitudinal study on 'Academic Persistence' that offers a 'Professional Stress-Management Workshop' as an incentive. According to the ethical standards for 'Offering Inducements for Research Participation,' which of the following recruitment scripts represents the most complete and synthesized integration of this professional service incentive?
When researchers offer professional services as an incentive for research participation, they are only obligated to explain the potential benefits of those services.
In an ethical review of research recruitment, when a researcher determines that a proposed incentive is so large it would likely impair a potential participant's ability to freely weigh the study's risks and benefits, they have evaluated the inducement as _____.
Match each research recruitment scenario to the appropriate ethical status or required action based on the APA Standard for offering inducements.
A researcher recruits participants for a study by offering free counseling sessions. However, the researcher fails to disclose that the therapy will be conducted by supervised student interns rather than licensed clinicians. In analyzing this ethical issue, the researcher has failed to clarify the _____ of the professional services offered as an inducement.
A researcher plans to offer free biofeedback training sessions to recruit participants. Arrange the steps of the ethical evaluation and planning process in the correct chronological order, from first to last.
Provide a concise analytical response describing the ethical guidelines researchers must follow when offering both financial inducements and professional services for research participation.
Diagnose the potential ethical issues in Dr. Smith's recruitment strategy and justify why these practices violate ethical standards regarding research inducements.
In a brief one- to three-sentence answer, explain what specific information a researcher must provide to potential participants if they decide to offer a free 10-week mindfulness training program as an incentive for a stress study.