Learn Before
Diagnose the status of this 1951 study within the context of literature review guidelines. Explain why the student is justified in including this older study in her literature review despite her instructor's general guideline to prioritize recent research.
Case context: A student is writing a literature review on social conformity in psychology. Her instructor instructed the class to prioritize research sources from the last 10 years to ensure their reviews are up to date. However, as the student searches the literature, she notices that a landmark study by Solomon Asch published in 1951 is cited in the reference lists of nearly every single recent paper she finds on the topic.
Question: Diagnose the status of this 1951 study within the context of literature review guidelines. Explain why the student is justified in including this older study in her literature review despite her instructor's general guideline to prioritize recent research.
Sample answer: The student should diagnose this study as a classic article. Although it violates the general guideline of prioritizing recent research due to its age, its frequent presence in the reference lists of nearly every other source on conformity demonstrates that it is a foundational, highly influential study with enduring importance to the field. Because classic articles are the primary exception to the recency rule, the student is justified in including it regardless of its publication date.
Key points:
- Diagnoses the 1951 study as a classic article.
- Explains that being cited in nearly every other source on the topic indicates its foundational and highly influential status.
- Justifies the study's inclusion as the primary exception to the general rule of prioritizing recent research.
- Connects the justification to the study's enduring importance to the field of psychology.
Rubric: The response must correctly identify the 1951 study as a classic article. It must explain that its frequent citation across nearly all other sources on the topic demonstrates its foundational status and enduring importance. Finally, it must justify its inclusion as a valid exception to the general rule of prioritizing recent research.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
In the context of a literature review, what is the primary characteristic of a "classic article"?
A researcher conducting a literature review should include an older study primarily because it was published by a well-known psychologist, even if it is rarely cited in current research on the topic.
Imagine you are selecting sources for a literature review on human memory. Match each described study with its correct classification in your review process based on the principles of recency and foundational importance.
A researcher is evaluating a landmark study from 1971 to determine if it belongs in their current literature review. Arrange the steps of the analytical process the researcher should follow to justify including this older source as a 'classic article'.
In a psychological literature review, which type of research source serves as the primary exception to the general rule of prioritizing recent research?
True or False: In a literature review, a study's status as a 'classic article' is based on its enduring importance to the field, meaning it should be included even if more recent research on the same topic is available.
A researcher is critiquing a draft of a literature review that includes a source published in 1954. To justify the inclusion of this source as a valid exception to the standard requirement for recency, the researcher must evaluate if the work is considered a(n) _____ article based on its foundational impact and frequent citations in current literature.
A student is building a literature review on the psychology of conformity. Match each source description to the decision rule that should guide whether to include it in the review.
When a researcher finds that an older study appears in the reference lists of nearly every current source on a topic, this pattern of _____ is what distinguishes a classic article from an old article that simply lacks recent alternatives, and it is the primary analytical criterion that justifies breaking the recency rule.
A student discovers an article published in 1968 while searching for sources for a literature review on attachment theory. Arrange the following steps in the correct order to evaluate and justify whether the article meets the classic article exception and warrants inclusion in the review.
According to the guidelines for literature reviews, what is a "classic article," and how does it relate to the general rule of prioritizing recent research?
Diagnose the status of this 1951 study within the context of literature review guidelines. Explain why the student is justified in including this older study in her literature review despite her instructor's general guideline to prioritize recent research.
Imagine you are reviewing a classmate's draft of a literature review on attachment theory. They have included a study from 1958 but are worried it violates the rule of recency. What specific citation pattern should you instruct them to look for in their other, newer sources to justify keeping this 1958 study as a classic article?