Case Study

Diagnose the threat to internal validity created by the simultaneous installation of the new inventory system. Explain why the nonequivalent control group does not rule out this threat.

Case context: A research group evaluates a factory shift reduction from 1010 to 88 hours using an interrupted time-series design. The treatment factory installs a new automated inventory system at the same time as the shift reduction. A similar nonequivalent control factory does not implement the shift change or the new inventory system. Post-intervention data shows that the treatment factory's productivity increases while the control factory's productivity remains stable.

Question: Diagnose the threat to internal validity created by the simultaneous installation of the new inventory system. Explain why the nonequivalent control group does not rule out this threat.

Sample answer: The simultaneous installation of the new inventory system creates a history threat to internal validity, as it introduces a confounding variable occurring at the same time as the shift reduction. The nonequivalent control group does not rule out this threat because the control factory did not receive the new inventory system. Therefore, it is impossible to determine whether the increase in productivity was caused by the shift reduction, the new inventory system, or a combination of both.

Key points:

  • Diagnose the situation as containing a history threat or confounding variable (the inventory system upgrade).
  • Explain that the control group is ineffective here because it did not undergo the same simultaneous change.
  • Understand that the causal link between the shift reduction and productivity is now ambiguous.

Rubric: Grading should be based on the student's ability to identify the history threat (or confounding variable), explain why the control group fails to address it (due to only the treatment group receiving the inventory system), and conclude that causality is obscured.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related