Case Study

Evaluate the psychologist's recommendation. Explain the challenge of external validity in this scenario and explain why a strong treatment effect in this study does not automatically justify district-wide implementation for all children with intellectual delays.

Case context: A school psychologist conducts a single-subject research study to evaluate a new behavioral intervention aimed at reducing self-injury. The psychologist tests the intervention with 22 students who have intellectual disabilities and finds that the treatment is highly effective, drastically reducing self-injurious behaviors in both students. Based on this strong outcome, the psychologist recommends that the school district implement this intervention as the standard protocol for all students with intellectual delays.

Question: Evaluate the psychologist's recommendation. Explain the challenge of external validity in this scenario and explain why a strong treatment effect in this study does not automatically justify district-wide implementation for all children with intellectual delays.

Sample answer: The psychologist's recommendation is premature because a study involving only 22 children has limited external validity. While the treatment was highly effective for these specific individuals, we cannot assume that the success will generalize to the broader population of children with intellectual delays in the district. The psychologist must recognize that the treatment's effectiveness for other children who were not part of the original study remains an unresolved question.

Key points:

  • Success in 22 individuals does not guarantee the treatment will work for others.
  • The core issue is a limitation in external validity and generalizability.
  • The psychologist cannot assume the treatment applies to children with intellectual delays who were not in the original study.

Rubric: Full credit is awarded if the student explains that: 1) a strong effect in only 22 participants does not guarantee effectiveness in others, 2) this limitation is a concern of external validity or generalizability, and 3) the researcher cannot assume the treatment will work for other children with intellectual delays who were not part of the original study.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related