Learn Before
Evaluating a Market for Environmental Protection
Consider a government proposal to cap total industrial pollution. Under this system, a fixed number of 'permits to pollute' are created. A market is established where these permits can be freely bought and sold among firms. A key feature of this proposal is that anyone, including private citizens and environmental groups, can also purchase these permits on the open market and 'retire' them, meaning the corresponding amount of pollution can never be emitted.
Critique this proposal from an ethical and social standpoint. In your answer, evaluate the argument that this system corrupts the shared social value of environmental stewardship by turning it into a commodity that can be bought and sold. Weigh this concern against the argument that it is a practical mechanism allowing individuals to directly contribute to a public good. Conclude with your own reasoned judgment on the proposal.
0
1
Tags
Social Science
Empirical Science
Science
Economy
CORE Econ
Economics
Introduction to Microeconomics Course
The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Related
Analyzing a Controversial Market
Consider the proposition of creating an open market where university admission slots at elite institutions are sold to the highest bidder. The revenue generated would then be used to fully fund scholarships for numerous low-income students. Which of the following statements best represents an argument against this proposal based primarily on social or ethical constraints, rather than on grounds of economic efficiency or outcomes?
Match each potential market with the primary ethical or social argument used to argue against its existence.
The Price of Honor
Justifying Non-Market Goods
True or False: The argument that certain civic duties, like jury service, should not be buyable or sellable is primarily based on the principle that a market would be inefficient in selecting the most qualified jurors.
The Ethics of Queue-Jumping
Evaluating a Market for Environmental Protection
The Compromise on a Public Park
A city council is debating a proposal to allow a private, for-profit company to manage the city's public library system. Proponents argue this will increase efficiency. Three different arguments are raised in opposition. Which of the following arguments is based on the ethical view that the intrinsic character or social meaning of a service makes it unsuitable for market exchange, rather than being based on the potential negative outcomes of such a transaction?
Moral Objections to a Market for Life-Saving Medical Care