Evaluating a Tradable Permit System's Effectiveness
A government authority has implemented a system to control the salinity of a river vital for local agriculture. The authority sets a total limit on salt discharge and issues a fixed number of tradable permits to industrial firms located along the river. After several years, the following outcomes are observed:
- The overall salinity level of the river has decreased and is now below the target set by the authority.
- Firms with lower costs for reducing salt discharge have sold their excess permits for a significant profit.
- Firms with higher costs for reducing salt discharge have had to purchase expensive permits, leading to increased operational costs.
- A concentration of salt discharge has occurred in one specific section of the river, negatively impacting a small number of farms located downstream from a cluster of firms that purchased permits.
Evaluate the overall success of this tradable permit system. In your evaluation, you must weigh the economic efficiency demonstrated by the market against the environmental outcomes, including any unintended consequences.
0
1
Tags
Social Science
Empirical Science
Science
Ch.1 The Capitalist Revolution - The Economy 1.0 @ CORE Econ
The Economy 1.0 @ CORE Econ
CORE Econ
Economy
Economics
Ch.10 Market successes and failures: The societal effects of private decisions - The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Introduction to Microeconomics Course
The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Evaluation in Bloom's Taxonomy
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
Related
Analyzing Market Reactions to Environmental Changes
A government authority manages a river's water quality by setting a limit on the total amount of salty water that can be discharged by industrial firms. The authority issues a fixed number of permits, each allowing a certain amount of discharge, and firms can buy and sell these permits from one another. If the authority decides to reduce the total number of available permits to further protect the local ecosystem, what is the most likely immediate consequence in the market for these permits, assuming industrial demand for discharging salty water remains the same?
Cost-Effective Pollution Reduction via Permit Trading
Firm Decision-Making in a Permit Market
A government authority manages a river's water quality by setting a limit on the total amount of salty water that can be discharged by industrial firms. The authority issues a fixed number of permits, each allowing a certain amount of discharge, and firms can buy and sell these permits from one another. If a new, low-cost technology becomes available that allows firms to reduce the salt content of their discharge, how does this tradable permit system influence the adoption of the new technology compared to a system where each firm is simply assigned a strict, non-tradable discharge limit?
Policy Response to Environmental Shocks in a Permit Market
Evaluating a Tradable Permit System's Effectiveness
Evaluating the Design of a Water Salinity Permit System
A government authority is tasked with protecting sensitive agricultural areas along a river from damage caused by high water salinity from industrial discharge. They decide to implement a system where a total limit is set on salty water discharge, and permits corresponding to this limit are issued and can be traded among firms. What is a primary advantage of this tradable permit system compared to an alternative policy of simply charging a fixed fee for each unit of salty water discharged?
Analyzing Unintended Consequences of a Tradable Permit System
Firm Decision-Making in a Permit Market