Learn Before
Evaluating Investment Advice
An investor, after reading several alarming news reports about economic uncertainty, becomes significantly more cautious and uncomfortable with the level of risk in their stock portfolio. They consult two different financial advisors for advice.
- Advisor A states: "Because your personal willingness to accept risk has decreased, the market will now have to offer you a higher expected return to compensate you for holding these same stocks. The risk premium on your assets has effectively increased for you."
- Advisor B states: "Your personal feelings about risk have changed, but that doesn't change the objective market-wide compensation for holding those stocks. The risk premium is determined by the collective judgment of all market participants, not by one person's change of heart. You should adjust your portfolio to match your new comfort level, but you shouldn't expect the assets themselves to offer a different premium."
Based on the principles that determine an asset's compensation for risk, which advisor's reasoning is more accurate? Explain your choice.
0
1
Tags
Economics
Economy
Introduction to Macroeconomics Course
Ch.5 Macroeconomic policy: Inflation and unemployment - The Economy 2.0 Macroeconomics @ CORE Econ
The Economy 2.0 Macroeconomics @ CORE Econ
CORE Econ
Social Science
Empirical Science
Science
Evaluation in Bloom's Taxonomy
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
Related
An individual investor, who is one of many thousands holding a particular stock, suddenly becomes much more cautious and decides they are no longer willing to accept the same level of investment uncertainty. Based on the principles that determine an asset's compensation for risk, what is the most likely effect of this single investor's change in personal attitude on the stock's overall market risk premium?
A financial analyst argues that if a large group of investors simultaneously becomes more willing to accept uncertainty, the risk premium on a specific corporate bond will decrease, even if the company's probability of defaulting on that bond remains exactly the same. This analyst's argument is correct.
Market vs. Individual Determinants of Risk Premium
Analyzing Changes in Risk Premiums
Individual vs. Market Influence on Risk Premium
Match each concept to its correct description regarding the determination of an asset's risk premium.
The compensation required for holding a risky asset is determined by the objective ______, not by the subjective preferences of a single investor.
Source of Change in Corporate Bond Risk Premium
Two corporate bonds, Bond A and Bond B, are issued by companies with identical credit ratings and default probabilities. However, financial markets consistently demand a higher risk premium for Bond A than for Bond B. Which of the following statements provides the most valid explanation for this difference, based on the principles of how risk premiums are determined?
Evaluating Investment Advice