Learn Before
Case Study

Explain why Dr. Aris's experimental design is not possible. Describe the methodological change she must make to study this relationship, and identify what specific type of approach she must adopt.

Case context: Dr. Aris wants to study the effect of significant early childhood illness on the development of hypochondriasis. She considers designing an experiment where she randomly assigns infants to either a group that is exposed to pathogens causing early illness or a control group that is kept in a sterile environment.

Question: Explain why Dr. Aris's experimental design is not possible. Describe the methodological change she must make to study this relationship, and identify what specific type of approach she must adopt.

Sample answer: Dr. Aris's experimental design is not possible because it is highly unethical to intentionally expose infants to pathogens that cause significant early illness. Since active manipulation of early illness is ethically impossible, Dr. Aris cannot perform a true experiment. She must instead use a nonexperimental approach to investigate the relationship between early illness and hypochondriasis.

Key points:

  • Intentionally causing significant early childhood illness is ethically impossible.
  • Active manipulation of whether individuals suffer a significant early illness is not possible.
  • When active manipulation is impossible, a true experiment cannot be conducted.
  • The researcher must use a nonexperimental approach to study the relationship between early illness and hypochondriasis.

Rubric: The student must explain that exposing infants to illness is unethical, making active manipulation of the independent variable impossible. They must state that Dr. Aris needs to switch from an experimental design to a nonexperimental approach.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related