Case Study

Explain why the student's method of using the total sample size instead of calculating the degrees of freedom is incorrect. Describe what the degrees of freedom should be for this study and how this value affects the distribution used to find the pp value.

Case context: An undergraduate psychology student is conducting a study to see if the average anxiety scores of a sample of 12 students differ from a known population mean. The student conducts a one-sample tt-test but uses the total sample size of 12 to look up the probability of their test statistic on a general tt distribution chart, rather than calculating degrees of freedom first.

Question: Explain why the student's method of using the total sample size instead of calculating the degrees of freedom is incorrect. Describe what the degrees of freedom should be for this study and how this value affects the distribution used to find the pp value.

Sample answer: The student's method is incorrect because the shape of the tt distribution is dictated by the degrees of freedom (dfdf), not the raw sample size (NN). For this study, the degrees of freedom should be calculated as Nāˆ’1N - 1, which is 12āˆ’1=1112 - 1 = 11. This specific calculation of df=11df = 11 dictates the exact shape of the tt distribution, enabling the student to accurately identify the pp value associated with their test statistic.

Key points:

  • Explain that using the raw sample size to find the pp value is incorrect.
  • Calculate the correct degrees of freedom for the study as 1111 using Nāˆ’1N - 1.
  • Explain that the degrees of freedom calculation dictates the exact shape of the tt distribution.
  • Explain that determining the exact shape of the tt distribution is necessary to accurately identify the pp value.

Rubric: The response must explain that degrees of freedom (df=11df = 11) must be used instead of sample size because the dfdf dictates the exact shape of the tt distribution, which is necessary to accurately identify the pp value.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-26

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related