In the peer review process, scientists with relevant expertise evaluate a submitted research article, typically anonymously. They serve as a critical filter, distinguishing ideas that are well-supported by evidence from those that are not, while also providing constructive feedback on the manuscript's quality to both the author and the journal editor.

Role of Peer Reviewers

Following the evaluation by peer reviewers, a journal editor synthesizes the feedback to make a final decision on the manuscript. The possible outcomes include publishing the article as is, which is uncommon; publishing it after the author makes required revisions; or rejecting it for publication.

Outcomes of the Peer Review Process

The peer review process serves several key functions in maintaining the integrity of psychological research. It acts as a quality control mechanism by filtering out poorly conceived or executed studies and suggesting improvements for well-designed research. It also helps prevent the publication of redundant findings, ensures that each article contributes new information, and confirms that the research is described with enough clarity to allow for replication by other scientists.

Benefits of Peer Review in Psychology

The American Psychological Association (APA) style is a specific writing and formatting standard that researchers typically must follow when preparing a manuscript for publication in a psychology journal. Students in psychology courses are expected to learn the major elements of this rigorous style.

APA Style

Which of the following is a required step before a manuscript is accepted for publication in a peer-reviewed scientific journal?

Publishing a manuscript in a peer-reviewed scientific journal is widely considered the most prestigious method for researchers to share their findings. Before a manuscript is accepted, it undergoes a rigorous evaluation process where other experts in the field anonymously review the work to ensure it meets scientific standards.

Google

University of Chicago

New Mexico Highlands University

Many researchers in psychology want to share their findings with their peers and other scholars in the field. Generally, researchers will publish peer-reviewed journal articles. 

Reporting Research in Psychology

The final step of the research process is reporting the results, which allows scientists to share their findings with the broader community. The most common methods for disseminating research include publishing articles in peer-reviewed journals, contributing chapters to edited books, and giving presentations at academic conferences.

Reporting Scientific Results

Spielman, R. M., Jenkins, W. J., & Lovett, M. D. (2020, April 22). Psychology (2nd ed.). OpenStax. https://openstax.org/books/psychology-2e/pages/1-introduction

OpenStax Psychology (2nd ed.) Textbook

https://kpu.pressbooks.pub/psychmethods4e/

KPU Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition

Peer-Reviewed Scientific Journal

An alternative method for researchers to report their findings is by writing a chapter for an edited book. While it is ideal for the book's editor to subject the chapter to a rigorous peer-review process, this is not guaranteed, as editors sometimes directly invite scientists to contribute chapters without formal review.

Academic Book Chapter

Professional conferences are key venues where researchers share their findings with colleagues. In psychology, research-focused conferences vary widely in scale, from small afternoon gatherings of a dozen researchers to large, multi-day conventions with thousands of attendees. While participants frequently discuss their work informally, research is officially disseminated through formal presentations, which primarily consist of oral talks and visual poster sessions.

Professional Conferences

Professional journals are periodicals that publish original research articles, typically issued on a monthly or quarterly basis in volumes. As a primary component of the research literature, they undergo a rigorous peer review process to ensure quality and primarily feature empirical research reports and review articles.

Professional Journals

Edited volumes are scholarly books in which an editor or an editorial team recruits various authors to write separate chapters on different aspects of a shared topic. While they aim to provide a coherent overview, different chapters may present distinct perspectives or feature authors who openly disagree with one another.

Edited Volumes

Scientific communication is the process of sharing research ideas, methods, results, and interpretations through formats such as journal articles, review articles, professional conferences, and poster sessions.

Learn Before

Related

Learn After