Policy Analysis: Wage Increase vs. Unearned Income Grant
A government wants to implement a policy to increase the well-being (utility) of a group of workers to a specific target level. After analysis, they determine that two different policies would achieve this identical target utility level for a typical worker who currently earns a wage of $96 per day:
Policy A: Increase the worker's daily wage to $150. Policy B: Provide the worker with a direct, unearned cash grant of $1,560, while their wage remains at $96 per day.
Evaluate these two policies from the perspective of their impact on labor supply. In your response, explain which policy would likely lead to the worker choosing to work more hours and justify your conclusion by analyzing how each policy affects the relative price of leisure.
0
1
Tags
Science
Economy
CORE Econ
Social Science
Empirical Science
Economics
Introduction to Microeconomics Course
The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Ch.3 Doing the best you can: Scarcity, wellbeing, and working hours - The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Evaluation in Bloom's Taxonomy
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
Related
The Income Effect in Figure E3.4 (Movement from A to C)
Analysis of Work-Leisure Choices
An economist determines that for a specific individual, a wage increase from $10 per hour to $15 per hour results in the same level of overall satisfaction (utility) as receiving a one-time, unconditional cash payment of $1,000 while their wage remains at $10 per hour. Based on this information, how would the individual's choice of leisure hours compare between these two equivalent-utility scenarios?
Analysis of Equivalent Utility Scenarios
If an individual can achieve an identical level of overall satisfaction (utility) from two different situations — one with a higher wage rate and another with their original, lower wage rate plus a lump-sum cash payment — they will choose to work the same number of hours in both situations.
Policy Analysis: Wage Increase vs. Unearned Income Grant
An economic advisor proposes two policies to help a low-wage worker reach a specific, higher level of well-being (utility).
- Policy A: Increase the worker's hourly wage.
- Policy B: Give the worker a one-time cash grant, keeping the original wage.
Both policies are carefully calculated to allow the worker to achieve the exact same, higher level of overall satisfaction. Which of the following statements accurately analyzes the effect of these two policies on the worker's choice between work and leisure?
An individual can reach an identical, higher level of satisfaction through two different scenarios. Match each scenario with the correct description of its impact on the person's choice between work and leisure.
Designing a Work-Leisure Incentive Program
An individual finds that their overall satisfaction is identical in two separate scenarios: (A) their hourly wage is significantly increased, and (B) they receive a large, one-time cash payment while their wage remains at the original, lower rate. Why would this individual likely choose to work more hours in scenario (A) than in scenario (B)?
Explaining Different Choices Under Equivalent Utility