Review Requests, Acceptances and Completions Count Different Stages
PRiMER’s report (23 October 2025) examined requests to assess newly submitted research papers, excluding revisions, from January 2017 through 31 July 2025. Its partial-2025 row lists 381 requests, 147 acceptances and 112 completed reviews. Requests are counted invitations, not necessarily different people. Acceptance uses 147 out of 381 requests; completion after acceptance uses 112 out of 147 acceptances. Per 100 expresses the same share out of 100 of that unit: about 39 acceptances per 100 requests versus 76 completions per 100 acceptances. The single-journal analysis identifies no cause or AI burden; these stage counts measure neither recurring participation nor correctness. All time and annual totals conflict: requests total 2,951 versus an annual-row sum of 2,927. No reconciliation is assumed.
0
1
Tags
Scientific Oversight of AI-Assisted Research
1Cademy