Separating Irreducible Error from Remediable Error in a Document Classifier
Case context: A team is building a document classifier for sorting incoming service requests. The current model makes errors on 24% of the dev set. After reviewing the task, the team estimates that even a perfect classifier would still miss 10% of cases because some messages are ambiguous, incomplete, or use overlapping categories.
Question: How should the 10% figure be interpreted, and what does that imply about the remaining 14% of the dev set error?
Sample answer: The 10% should be treated as the best achievable error rate, meaning it is the unavoidable portion of error for this task. That leaves 14% of the dev set error as the part the team should still try to reduce through better modeling, features, or training.
Key points:
- Identifies the 10% as the best achievable error rate.
- Recognizes that this portion is unavoidable for the task.
- Concludes that the remaining 14% is the part to target for improvement.
Rubric: The response must identify the 10% as the best achievable/irreducible error and state that the team should focus improvement efforts on the remaining 14% because the 10% cannot be eliminated.
0
1
Tags
Machine Learning
Deep Learning
Machine Learning Strategy
Supervised Learning
Dive into Deep Learning @ D2L
Data Science
Machine Learning Yearning @ DeepLearning.AI
Related
Optimal Error Rate Changes How Training Error Is Interpreted
What Is Irreducible Error?
Optimal Error Rate and Avoidable Bias
An Optimal Error Rate Reflects _____ Bias
Match the error terms to their meanings.
Recognizing the Irreducible Error Floor in a New Task
Interpreting Irreducible Error in Model Evaluation
The Error That Cannot Be Reduced Further
What Does a 14% Error Floor Represent?
Unavoidable bias is mainly a useful idea when the best possible error is already close to zero.
Related
Optimal Error Rate Changes How Training Error Is Interpreted
What Is Irreducible Error?
Optimal Error Rate and Avoidable Bias
An Optimal Error Rate Reflects _____ Bias
Match the error terms to their meanings.
Recognizing the Irreducible Error Floor in a New Task
Interpreting Irreducible Error in Model Evaluation
The Error That Cannot Be Reduced Further
What Does a 14% Error Floor Represent?
Unavoidable bias is mainly a useful idea when the best possible error is already close to zero.