Separating Irreducible Error from Remediable Error in a Document Classifier
Case context: A team is building a document classifier for sorting incoming service requests. The current model makes errors on 24% of the dev set. After reviewing the task, the team estimates that even a perfect classifier would still miss 10% of cases because some messages are ambiguous, incomplete, or use overlapping categories.
Question: How should the 10% figure be interpreted, and what does that imply about the remaining 14% of the dev set error?
Sample answer: The 10% should be treated as the best achievable error rate, meaning it is the unavoidable portion of error for this task. That leaves 14% of the dev set error as the part the team should still try to reduce through better modeling, features, or training.
Key points:
- Identifies the 10% as the best achievable error rate.
- Recognizes that this portion is unavoidable for the task.
- Concludes that the remaining 14% is the part to target for improvement.
Rubric: The response must identify the 10% as the best achievable/irreducible error and state that the team should focus improvement efforts on the remaining 14% because the 10% cannot be eliminated.
0
1
Tags
Machine Learning
Deep Learning
Machine Learning Strategy
Supervised Learning
Dive into Deep Learning @ D2L
Data Science
Machine Learning Yearning @ DeepLearning.AI
Related
Optimal Error Rate Changes How Training Error Is Interpreted
What Is Irreducible Error?
Optimal Error Rate and Avoidable Bias
An Optimal Error Rate Reflects _____ Bias
Match the error terms to their meanings.
Recognizing the Irreducible Error Floor in a New Task
Interpreting Irreducible Error in Model Evaluation
Separating Irreducible Error from Remediable Error in a Document Classifier
The Error That Cannot Be Reduced Further
What Does a 14% Error Floor Represent?
Unavoidable bias is mainly a useful idea when the best possible error is already close to zero.