When a Direct Model Is a Good Idea
Case context: A robotics team is developing software that converts streams from thermal sensors, vibration readings, and a few camera measurements into control commands for a sorting machine. A manager wants one model to learn the entire mapping from the raw signals to the final actions. The team, however, has only a small number of verified examples showing the correct command for each sensor reading.
Question: What should you tell the manager about using a fully direct model here, and what is the main reason?
Sample answer: I would not recommend relying on a fully direct model at this point. Approaches that learn the full input-to-output mapping usually depend on a large collection of labeled examples that pair each input with the correct output. Since this project has only a small set of verified sensor-command pairs, the model is unlikely to learn the task well.
Key points:
- Do not rely on a fully direct model yet
- These methods usually need many labeled input-output pairs
- Too little paired data makes the model hard to train well
Rubric: 1 point for advising against a fully direct model at this stage. 1 point for explaining that such models need many labeled input-output pairs. 1 point for stating that the limited paired data makes training difficult.
0
1
Tags
Machine Learning
Deep Learning
Supervised Learning
Dive into Deep Learning @ D2L
Data Science
Machine Learning Strategy
Machine Learning Yearning @ DeepLearning.AI
Related
What labeled pairs are needed to train a pure end-to-end delivery-drone controller?
Even with lots of labeled examples, an end-to-end model is not automatically the best design choice.
To train a camera-guided delivery robot end to end, you need many (Image, _____) pairs.
Match each application to the labeled input-output data it needs for end-to-end training.
Order the chain that explains why an end-to-end warehouse robot is hard to train.
Why would training a pure end-to-end warehouse robot require specially equipped robots?
End-to-end learning usually works best when many labeled input-output pairs are available.
If paired examples are scarce, you should treat end-to-end learning with great _____.
Match each autonomous driving data-collection challenge with its consequence.
Order the reasoning steps for deciding whether a single end-to-end model is practical for a new task.
Training Data Demands for Direct Control Models
When a Direct Model Is a Good Idea
Physical Inputs Needed to Gather Training Data