Case Study

Analyze how correcting the standard deviation of Group 2 from 5 to 10 affects each component of the independent-samples tt-test formula's denominator and the final tt statistic, assuming all other values remain constant.

Case context: A research team runs an independent-samples tt-test to compare the effects of two study techniques on exam scores. Group 1 (n1=25n_1 = 25) has M1=78M_1 = 78 and SD1=10SD_1 = 10. Group 2 (n2=25n_2 = 25) has M2=72M_2 = 72 and SD2=5SD_2 = 5. Later, they realize the standard deviation of Group 2 was recorded incorrectly and is actually SD2=10SD_2 = 10 instead of 5.

Question: Analyze how correcting the standard deviation of Group 2 from 5 to 10 affects each component of the independent-samples tt-test formula's denominator and the final tt statistic, assuming all other values remain constant.

Sample answer: Increasing SD2SD_2 from 5 to 10 increases the variance (SD22SD_2^2) from 25 to 100. Consequently, the term SD22/n2SD_2^2 / n_2 increases from 25/25=125 / 25 = 1 to 100/25=4100 / 25 = 4. This increases the sum of the variances divided by their sample sizes inside the square root from 4+1=54 + 1 = 5 to 4+4=84 + 4 = 8, which in turn increases the entire denominator (the square root of the sum) from 52.236\sqrt{5} \approx 2.236 to 82.828\sqrt{8} \approx 2.828. Because the denominator increases while the numerator (the mean difference M1M2=6M_1 - M_2 = 6) remains constant, the final calculated tt statistic decreases (from 6/2.2362.686 / 2.236 \approx 2.68 to 6/2.8282.126 / 2.828 \approx 2.12).

Key points:

  • Identify that the variance (SD squared) of Group 2 increases from 25 to 100.
  • Identify that the term SD2^2 / n2 increases from 1 to 4.
  • Identify that the sum inside the square root in the denominator increases (from 5 to 8).
  • Identify that the denominator (square root of the sum) increases.
  • Explain that a larger denominator with a constant numerator leads to a smaller overall t statistic.

Rubric: Student must trace the change from standard deviation to variance, show how this increases the specific group's variance/n term, explain how this increases the overall denominator, and conclude that an increased denominator with a constant numerator results in a smaller final t statistic.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related