Short Answer

Apply your understanding of research design limitations to the case study of H.M. Explain how the unique nature of a single-subject case study (specifically one involving surgical treatment for severe epilepsy) limits a researcher's ability to generalize these findings to the broader human population (external validity).

Question: Apply your understanding of research design limitations to the case study of H.M. Explain how the unique nature of a single-subject case study (specifically one involving surgical treatment for severe epilepsy) limits a researcher's ability to generalize these findings to the broader human population (external validity).

Sample answer: Relying on a single-subject case study like H.M. limits external validity because his brain may have undergone atypical developmental or neurological changes due to a history of severe epilepsy prior to surgery. Consequently, we cannot assume that the exact functional localization of memory consolidation in his temporal lobes represents typical brain organization in the broader, healthy population.

Key points:

  • Single-subject case studies inherently limit external validity (generalizability).
  • Pre-existing severe epilepsy could have altered H.M.'s neural pathways or brain organization.
  • Results from a single, unique surgical intervention cannot be assumed to represent the typical human population.

Rubric: The response must apply the concept of external validity to H.M.'s case, identifying that a single individual with severe epilepsy may have an atypical brain organization, which prevents researchers from generalizing the findings directly to the broader population.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-26

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related