Evaluating the Labor Market Impact of a Universal Basic Income
A government is considering implementing a policy that would provide every adult citizen with a fixed, unconditional monthly payment, regardless of their employment status. Two opposing arguments have emerged:
Argument A: "This policy will cause a significant number of people to reduce their work hours or leave the workforce entirely, as they will prefer more free time now that their basic income is secure."
Argument B: "This policy will have a minimal impact on work hours. Most people will continue to work the same amount because they desire a level of consumption and a lifestyle that the payment alone cannot support."
Critique the economic reasoning behind both arguments. Your task is to evaluate which argument is more plausible under different assumptions about individual preferences for consumption versus free time. Conclude by explaining why the overall effect on the labor supply is uncertain.
0
1
Tags
Science
Economy
CORE Econ
Social Science
Empirical Science
Economics
Introduction to Microeconomics Course
The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Ch.3 Doing the best you can: Scarcity, wellbeing, and working hours - The Economy 2.0 Microeconomics @ CORE Econ
Evaluation in Bloom's Taxonomy
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
Related
The Positive Income Effect of a Gift (Figure 3.11)
Zero Income Effect on Free Time (Figure 3.12)
Two individuals, Sofia and Liam, both receive an unexpected, permanent increase in their daily non-wage income. Sofia has a strong preference for leisure and relaxation. Liam has a strong preference for consuming goods, which he purchases with his wage earnings. Assuming both can freely choose their hours of work, which of the following statements best analyzes the most likely change in their choice of free time?
Analyzing Work-Leisure Choices
Analyzing Preferences and Work Choices
An individual's response to a change in non-wage income depends on their personal preferences for consumption and free time. Match each description of an individual's preferences to the most likely outcome on their choice of free time after receiving a significant, unconditional cash gift.
An individual who works 40 hours per week receives a large, unconditional cash inheritance. After receiving the inheritance, they continue to work 40 hours per week. This outcome implies that the individual places no value on having additional free time.
Analyzing Responses to Increased Income
An individual receives a significant, unexpected increase in their daily non-wage income. They have a very strong preference for material goods over leisure. As a result of this income increase, the change in the number of hours they choose for free time each day will be close to ______.
Consider an individual's choice between daily consumption and hours of free time, represented on a graph where the budget constraint shows all possible combinations. The individual receives a significant, unconditional daily payment that does not depend on work hours, causing their budget constraint to shift outward, parallel to the original. On this new, higher budget constraint, they choose a new point that involves more consumption but fewer hours of free time than their initial choice. What does this behavioral change reveal about the individual's preferences?
Predicting Labor Supply Responses to a Grant
Evaluating the Labor Market Impact of a Universal Basic Income
Unearned Income vs. Wage Increase on Work-Leisure Choice