Evidence of 1cademy assisting users' meaningful learning through its hierarchical organization
Question Imagine you want to review one of the concepts that you learned, to what extent would you prefer to review it on our collaborative maps in comparison to conventional course textbooks/lecture notes?
Relevant answer(s) "I enjoyed using one academy."
"It’s more structured"
Question "To what extent did you find it helpful to be able to navigate through the parent/child links in the hierarchically structured map?"
Relevant answer(s) "It is looking at the trickling of information. I could use the search tool, find a concept, then work backwards or forwards to see how it was derived or where it leads to"
"helped build logical connections"
"It was beneficial to have a hierarchical structure. For example, I often use a mind map to study. An advantage of the mind map is more freestyle in that I and can write things down and connect concepts/topics later to make connections. It tends to have radiation structure (expanding from the center to the outer), if not somewhat disorganized. But with the hierarchical map, such as 1Cademy, provided more structure between nodes, thus helped me to organize my thinking better."
"That's the only way to navigate effectively."
Question Throughout the semester, we had presented either by going through the hierarchical topics or by presenting specific nodes students had prepared to present. Which method did you think was more effective for your learning and why?
Relevant Answer(s) "Hierarchical topics helped understand the flow of information better - especially towards the end of the semester."
"Hierarchal ones. I prefer learning through a structured schedule."
"I think going through topics was by far the best way of doing it. It can be disorienting to jump around from topic to topic, but I felt I could gain a deeper understanding of principles if we allowed students to present their nodes on similar and related topics."
"Heirarchical topics was much more effective to me because I felt when students chose to present they would start talking about an obscure topic and then we would spend most of the class on something very specific while I sometimes still did not understand the overarching concept."
0
1
Tags
CSCW (Computer-supported cooperative work) ACM Conference
CSCW (Computer-supported cooperative work)
Computing Sciences