Learn Before
Example of Undisguised Participant Observation: Wilkins' Study
Sociologist Amy Wilkins provided an example of undisguised participant observation in her 2008 study of a university-based religious group that strongly emphasized member happiness. Over the course of 12 months, Wilkins actively participated in the group's events and conducted interviews, while being open about her role as a researcher. She found that the group maintained its happy facade by constantly discussing happiness, suppressing negative emotions, and using their cheerful disposition to separate themselves from outsiders.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Example of Undisguised Participant Observation: Wilkins' Study
What is a primary vulnerability of undisguised participant observation?
A psychology researcher is planning a study using undisguised participant observation. Match each core element of this research approach with the corresponding description of how it functions in the study.
A researcher joins a peer-support group for grief to study social support. He introduces himself as a psychologist and explains his research goals before attending the sessions as an active member. If the group members begin to speak more formally and hide their true emotions because they are aware they are being observed, the study is experiencing the specific phenomenon called participant reactivity.
A social psychologist is conducting an undisguised participant observation of a local support group. Arrange the following events to illustrate the causal chain through which this specific research method can lead to a reduction in the accuracy of the study's findings.
Compared to disguised approaches, undisguised participant observation is less vulnerable to participant reactivity because the participants are fully aware of the researcher's presence.
In psychological research, which statement best explains the methodology and primary limitation of undisguised participant observation?
A researcher is evaluating whether to use undisguised participant observation for a study on sensitive social interactions. They conclude that while the method is ethically sound due to open disclosure, the high potential for _____ makes it an inappropriate choice if the primary research goal is to observe completely natural, uninfluenced behavior.
Learn After
In Amy Wilkins' 2008 study of a university-based religious group, which of the following best describes her method of undisguised participant observation?
Based on Amy Wilkins' 2008 study of a university religious group, match each aspect of the research to the methodological role it represents.
Suppose you are planning a research study modeled after Amy Wilkins' 2008 study of a religious group. Arrange the following research steps in the correct order to successfully implement her methodology.
In Wilkins' study of a religious group, the finding that members used a 'happy facade' to separate themselves from outsiders suggests that her status as an undisguised researcher was a methodological asset for observing the group's boundary-maintenance behaviors.
Suppose you are tasked with designing a new behavioral coding system for a research project modeled after Wilkins' study of a university-based religious group. To investigate whether a similar 'happy facade' exists in a high-intensity corporate setting, which set of categories would you construct to best capture the emotional regulation and social boundary-maintenance behaviors she identified?
In her 2008 study of a university-based religious group, sociologist Amy Wilkins collected data using both active participant observation and interviews.
In the context of Amy Wilkins' (2008) study of a university religious group, match each behavioral strategy or outcome with the psychological or social function it performed within the group.
When evaluating the internal validity of Wilkins' study, a researcher must weigh the ethical benefits of her open role against the risk of _____, which occurs when participants alter their behavior because they are aware they are being observed.
In analyzing Wilkins' (2008) study of a university religious group, her use of both participant observation and _____ created a methodological advantage because behavioral patterns recorded through direct immersion could be cross-checked against members' own reported explanations for those patterns.
Imagine you are a peer reviewer evaluating the methodological rigor of Wilkins' (2008) undisguised participant observation study of a university religious group. Arrange the following evaluative steps in the order that best reflects sound critical appraisal, from the most foundational judgment to the most interpretive one.
Based on the provided details of Amy Wilkins' 2008 study, describe the methodology and key findings. In your description, identify the specific observational method used, the duration of the study, the dual methods of data collection, and the three behaviors the group used to maintain its happy facade.
Based on your understanding of Wilkins' study, justify the decision to use an undisguised approach over a disguised approach in this scenario. Discuss how this decision impacts the ethical nature of the study and the potential threat of participant reactivity.
Imagine you are designing an undisguised participant observation study to examine the group dynamics of a local community volunteer association. Applying the methodology used in Wilkins' 2008 study, describe how you would structure your data collection during the field immersion.