Learn Before
Explain how this scenario is analogous to the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth discussed in the text, and describe why relying on systematic empirical research, rather than intuition or common sense, is necessary for the psychologist to draw accurate conclusions about human behavior.
Case context: A developmental psychologist is reviewing a series of popular self-help articles claiming that children raised in highly anxious households develop a specific personality profile marked by risk aversion and social isolation. Recognizing the popularity of this claim, the psychologist decides to look for systematic empirical studies evaluating children of anxious parents compared to a control group rather than relying on intuition.
Question: Explain how this scenario is analogous to the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth discussed in the text, and describe why relying on systematic empirical research, rather than intuition or common sense, is necessary for the psychologist to draw accurate conclusions about human behavior.
Sample answer: This scenario is analogous because it involves a popular, plausible-sounding claim that a specific upbringing leads to a distinct personality profile, similar to the adult children of alcoholics myth. Relying on systematic empirical research is necessary because intuition and common sense can be misleading; empirical research uses controlled comparisons to determine whether the target group actually experiences these psychological issues at higher rates than the general population, preventing the psychologist from accepting an unsubstantiated myth as fact.
Key points:
- The popular claim about anxious households mirrors the adult children of alcoholics myth by asserting a distinct personality profile.
- Intuition and common sense are insufficient and can lead to unscientific beliefs.
- Systematic empirical research is required to objectively test claims about human behavior.
- Empirical research compares groups to verify whether specific psychological traits are actually more common in the target population.
Rubric: The response must explain the analogy (a popular but unverified claim of a distinct personality profile based on parental background) and explain why empirical research is needed to verify the claim (intuition can be wrong, and systematic studies compare groups to see if the rate of psychological problems is truly different).
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Systematic empirical research has shown that adult children of alcoholics are significantly more likely than others to display a distinct personality profile characterized by low self-esteem, feelings of powerlessness, and difficulties with intimacy.
How does the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth illustrate the importance of using systematic empirical research rather than relying on intuition to understand human behavior?
A team of researchers and clinicians are evaluating claims about the psychological effects of growing up in an alcoholic household. Match each scenario with the concept it best demonstrates regarding the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' (ACOA) personality profile.
A researcher is evaluating whether a 'distinct personality profile' truly exists for adult children of alcoholics. Arrange the components of their scientific investigation in the correct logical order to demonstrate how empirical evidence is used to analyze and debunk this psychological myth.
According to the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth, what is necessary for answering questions about human behavior rather than relying on intuition or common sense?
Match each element of the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' personality profile discussion with the role it plays in understanding psychological research methods.
A journalist publishes a widely-shared article claiming that children raised in households with a depressed parent consistently develop a distinct personality profile marked by chronic pessimism and poor social skills. Applying the lesson illustrated by the adult children of alcoholics research, a psychology student is justified in accepting this claim as valid because it appears across many popular media outlets and sounds psychologically plausible.
The adult children of alcoholics myth contains an implicit testable prediction: that adult children of alcoholics will experience low self-esteem, feelings of powerlessness, and difficulties with intimacy at _____ rates than the general population — a prediction that systematic empirical research found to be unsupported.
A student encounters the popular claim that adult children of alcoholics share a distinct personality profile. Arrange the following steps in the order that best reflects sound scientific reasoning when evaluating the credibility of a popular psychological claim.
When evaluating the scientific validity of the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' personality profile, the most critical standard for judging the claim as a myth is its failure to hold up under _____ research.
According to the provided text about the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth, state the three specific psychological traits that are popularly but unscientifically believed to characterize this distinct personality profile, and identify what systematic empirical research has demonstrated concerning these individuals.
Explain how this scenario is analogous to the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth discussed in the text, and describe why relying on systematic empirical research, rather than intuition or common sense, is necessary for the psychologist to draw accurate conclusions about human behavior.
Imagine you are designing a study to test the 'Adult Children of Alcoholics' myth. Operationally define the group status variable, and explain what findings would support the myth versus what findings would align with the empirical research cited in the text.