Case Study

Explain why Dr. Martinez cannot assume that the cognitive intervention will reduce Sarah's test anxiety, and describe the possible outcomes Sarah might experience based on the arguments of single-subject researchers.

Case context: A clinical psychologist, Dr. Martinez, is reviewing a large-group study evaluating a new cognitive intervention for test anxiety. The study reports that, on average, the 300 participants who received the intervention showed a statistically significant reduction in anxiety levels. Dr. Martinez wants to apply this treatment to her client, Sarah.

Question: Explain why Dr. Martinez cannot assume that the cognitive intervention will reduce Sarah's test anxiety, and describe the possible outcomes Sarah might experience based on the arguments of single-subject researchers.

Sample answer: Dr. Martinez cannot assume the intervention will work for Sarah because an average effect in a large group does not guarantee how a specific individual will respond. Even though the group improved on average, Sarah's individual outcome could be highly positive (significant anxiety reduction), neutral (no change), or negative (increased anxiety).

Key points:

  • Group averages do not predict or guarantee individual outcomes.
  • Generalizing from a large group to an individual (Sarah) presents external validity challenges.
  • Sarah's individual response could be highly positive, negative, or neutral.

Rubric: To earn full credit, the student must explain that a group average cannot guarantee individual success due to individual variability, and specify that Sarah's response could be highly positive, negative, or neutral.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related