Learn Before
Risks and Benefits to Research Participants
When weighing risks against benefits in psychological research, investigators must consider the potential impacts on the participants themselves. Risks to participants may include a treatment failing to help or causing harm, a procedure resulting in physical or psychological distress, or a violation of their right to privacy. Conversely, potential benefits can encompass receiving a helpful treatment, learning about the field of psychology, experiencing the satisfaction of contributing to scientific knowledge, and receiving compensation such as money or course credit.
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Debriefing
Unjustifiable Research Harm
APA Ethics Code
Humane Care and Use of Animals in Research
Beneficiaries of Psychological Research
Unethical Research Motivations
Risks and Benefits to Research Participants
Risks and Benefits to Science and Society
Ethical Implications of the Milgram Experiment
Why can the ethical evaluation of weighing a study's risks against its benefits be particularly challenging for psychological researchers?
A psychological study can be considered ethically acceptable even when the research participants themselves bear most of the risks, as long as the potential benefits to the broader scientific community or society are judged to sufficiently outweigh those risks.
A researcher proposes a study to test if mild electric shocks can improve concentration in students with ADHD. To evaluate the ethics of this study, match each study element to its corresponding category in a risk-benefit analysis.
A researcher is evaluating the ethicality of a study on how social isolation affects mental health. Arrange the following steps in the logical order required to effectively weigh the potential risks of the study against its potential benefits.
A researcher is developing a study to investigate the impact of sleep deprivation on cognitive performance in emergency room doctors. The study requires participants to stay awake for hours while performing simulated surgical tasks. A review committee is concerned that the high risk of physical exhaustion outweighs the scientific benefits. Which of the following newly proposed research frameworks best synthesizes a solution to achieve an ethical balance?
In the process of weighing risks against benefits, different groups are affected in different ways. Match each entity involved in psychological research to the role it typically plays in this ethical evaluation.
Because the potential risks to individual participants and the potential benefits to the scientific community are not measured in the same units, the process of deciding if a study is ethically justified requires an inherently subjective ethical _____.
In psychological research ethics, the foundational principle states that a study is considered ethical only when its potential _____ outweigh its potential risks.
Learn After
When considering the potential impacts on participants in psychological research, which of the following describes a risk rather than a benefit?
A research team is reviewing participant experiences from a recently completed psychology study. Match each participant experience on the left to the specific type of risk or benefit it best represents on the right.
A researcher conducts a study on a new memory-enhancement technique. A participant finds that the technique fails to help improve their memory, but they are happy to receive $20 for their participation. In this situation, the $20 payment is classified as a benefit, while the failure of the technique to help is classified as a risk.
A research committee is evaluating the ethical balance of a new cognitive study. Analyze the following participant experiences and arrange them in the specified sequence of their classifications:
- Risk of treatment failure
- Risk of psychological distress
- Benefit of learning about psychology
- Benefit of compensation
You are designing an ethics proposal for a new study investigating a cognitive-behavioral intervention for insomnia. To ensure a balanced ethical design, you must construct a 'Risks and Benefits' section for the informed consent form that synthesizes potential impacts on participants. Which of the following sections best constructs this profile by including at least one risk of treatment failure, one risk to privacy, and at least two distinct categories of benefits?
In psychological research, the only potential risks to participants are physical and psychological distress.
In the ethical review of a research proposal, if an investigator determines that the potential for a participant to learn about psychology or receive compensation is not significant enough to justify the risk of psychological distress, they are judging that the _____ of the study do not outweigh its risks.
When researchers weigh the impacts of psychological studies on the participants themselves, outcomes like physical distress or a violation of privacy represent participant risks, whereas outcomes like learning about the field of psychology or receiving compensation represent participant _____.
An institutional review board is analyzing proposals for psychological research. Match each hypothetical participant experience on the left to the specific classification of risk or benefit from the ethical guidelines on the right.
Evaluate the ethical balance of risks and benefits in the following four proposed studies. Order the studies from the most ethically favorable balance (highest potential benefits with minimal/no risks to participants) to the least ethically favorable balance (highest potential risks with minimal/no benefits to participants).