Learn Before
دفتر پنجم - بخش ۱۶۷ - حجت منکران آخرت و بیان ضعف آن حجت زیرا حجت ایشان به دین باز میگردد کی غیر این نمیبینیم / Book Five - Section 167 - The argument of those who deny the Hereafter, and the demonstration of the weakness of that argument, because their argument returns to this: 'We do not see anything other than this'
دفتر پنجم - بخش ۱۶۷ - حجت منکران آخرت و بیان ضعف آن حجت زیرا حجت ایشان به دین باز میگردد کی غیر این نمیبینیم / Book Five - Section 167 - The Argument of the Deniers of the Hereafter and the Explanation of the Weakness of that Argument, because their argument returns to this: 'We do not see other than this'
The Critique of Sensual Empiricism and the Argument of the Deniers of the Hereafter in Book Five of the Masnavi
In Book Five of the Masnavi, Jalaluddin Rumi systematically critiques the epistemological stance of sensual empiricists and deniers of the Hereafter who argue that only what is visible or sensory exists ('We do not see anything other than this').
Rumi exposes the fallacy of this argument by presenting several analogies of progressive levels of perception:
- Intellect vs. Childhood: A child cannot perceive the state of intellect, yet the existence of intellect remains undeniable to a rational adult.
- Love vs. Reason: A purely rational person (the intellectual) cannot perceive the mysteries of spiritual love, yet love's reality is not diminished by their blindness.
- Spiritual vs. Physical Sight: Joseph's brothers saw only his physical form, while Jacob perceived his divine beauty. Similarly, Moses' staff appeared as mere wood to sensory eyes but was revealed as a formidable serpent to his spiritual eye ('chashm-e ghayb').
Through these analogies, Rumi argues that ...
0
1
Tags
Humanities
Literature
Islam
Religion
Science
Philosophy
Social Science
Persian Literature Prerequisite Course
Related
دفتر پنجم - بخش ۱۶۸ - آمدن خلیفه نزد آن خوبروی برای جماع / Book Five - Section 168 - The Caliph's Coming to That Beautiful Woman for Copulation
The Critique of Sensual Empiricism and the Argument of the Deniers of the Hereafter in Book Five of the Masnavi
دفتر پنجم - بخش ۱۶۸ - آمدن خلیفه نزد آن خوبروی برای جماع / Book Five - Section 168 - The Caliph's Coming to That Beautiful Woman for Copulation
The Critique of Sensual Empiricism and the Argument of the Deniers of the Hereafter in Book Five of the Masnavi