Proposed extension of 1Cademy’s topic/link decisions (undated page; captured 2026-11-09): track acceptance separately from each version-linked objection’s status. Candidate statuses: unresolved, answered but disputed, or closed with reasons; closure does not establish correctness. Retain concerns, responses and reasons. Name closure authority, disclose relevant relationships and record when qualified review is unavailable. Keep records inspectable, with prominence proportionate to support and consequence, not every dispute in beginners’ paths. Escalate within available capacity; restrict affected use when consequential concerns cannot be checked. Test comprehension, status-decision quality and total work. PubPeer’s indexed FAQ describes retained discussions and reply rights, not systematic dispute resolution; PCI RR’s guide permits burden-based screening (both undated; retrieved 2026-11-09). Policies do not demonstrate that this procedure works.