Learn Before
Based on the Belmont Report's ethical guidelines, explain how this study design violates the principle of seeking justice.
Case context: A research team plans to test an experimental vaccine. Because of high risk of side effects, they decide to recruit participants solely from prison populations, as they are a captive audience and easy to monitor. However, once the vaccine is proven safe and effective, it will only be distributed to the general public and will not be made available to the prison population.
Question: Based on the Belmont Report's ethical guidelines, explain how this study design violates the principle of seeking justice.
Sample answer: According to the Belmont Report, seeking justice requires distributing the risks and benefits of research fairly. In this case, the prison population bears all the risks of the experimental vaccine research, while the general public receives all the benefits, which is an unfair distribution.
Key points:
- Defines seeking justice as distributing risks and benefits fairly
- Explains that the prison population unfairly bears the risks of the research
- Explains that the benefits of the research are only distributed to the general public
- Concludes that this imbalance violates the ethical guidelines of the Belmont Report
Rubric: The answer should define justice in the context of the Belmont Report (fair distribution of risks and benefits) and explain how the case context violates this by making one group bear the risks (prisoners) while another benefits (the general public).
0
1
Tags
KPU
Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU
Related
Weighing Risks Against Benefits
Seeking Justice
Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects
Respecting People's Rights and Dignity
Match each core moral principle established by the Belmont Report with its corresponding description.
A researcher studying the effects of a new stress-reduction technique recruits participants exclusively from a low-income housing complex, even though the technique is intended to benefit all adults. The potential risks of the study are borne entirely by this economically disadvantaged group, while the benefits of the findings will be applied to the broader population. Which core ethical principle from the landmark 1978 federal guidelines for human-subjects research is most directly violated in this scenario?
A researcher is planning a study to investigate the effects of caffeine on memory performance. Arrange the following research actions in the order that they correctly demonstrate the application of these specific Belmont Report principles: Respect for Persons, then Beneficence, and finally Justice.
Under the Belmont Report's ethical framework, ensuring that a research study maintains a highly favorable risk-benefit ratio for its participants automatically guarantees that the principle of Justice has also been satisfied.
You are designing an original research protocol to test a new psychological intervention for foster children, a population considered vulnerable. To construct a study design that comprehensively synthesizes the three core moral principles of the 1978 federal guidelines for human subjects research (the Belmont Report), which of the following integrated strategies should you propose?
The Belmont Report is a set of United States federal guidelines that explicitly recognized three core moral principles for research: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.
An institutional review board evaluates a research proposal and determines that the study's design is unethical because the potential for psychological distress to the participants is not justified by the study's minimal scientific benefit. In making this judgment to prioritize participant welfare over the researcher's scientific goals, the board is primarily enforcing the Belmont Report principle of _____.
A researcher is making ethical decisions throughout the design and conduct of a study on chronic pain management. Match each of the following research actions to the Belmont Report principle it most directly exemplifies.
A research team studying a new antidepressant recruits participants exclusively from a Veterans Affairs hospital, even though the drug, if approved, will be marketed to the general public. An ethics reviewer concludes that this design violates the Belmont Report's principle of _____, because the burdens of participation fall disproportionately on one population group while the potential treatment benefits will be available to everyone.
An IRB is evaluating a proposed study on financial stress and decision-making that involves temporarily deceiving participants about whether their answers will affect their financial aid eligibility. Arrange the following IRB evaluation steps in the order they should be completed, from first (1) to last (5), to reflect sound Belmont-based ethical review.
Identify the year the Belmont Report was published, the primary historical study that prompted its creation, and list the three core moral principles for research that it established.
Based on the Belmont Report's ethical guidelines, explain how this study design violates the principle of seeking justice.
A researcher wants to study memory in children. Explain how the researcher should apply the Belmont Report's principle of respect for persons during the recruitment and enrollment process.