Case Study

Based on this scenario, decide whether the researcher should use a one-tailed or two-tailed alternative hypothesis for their dependent-samples tt-test. Justify your decision using the principles of hypothesis testing for difference scores.

Case context: A researcher is evaluating a new cognitive-behavioral therapy designed specifically to decrease symptom severity in patients with generalized anxiety disorder. They measure symptom severity using a standardized scale before the therapy begins and again after the therapy is completed. Based on previous literature, the researcher has strong theoretical reasons to expect that the therapy will only decrease symptoms, not increase them.

Question: Based on this scenario, decide whether the researcher should use a one-tailed or two-tailed alternative hypothesis for their dependent-samples tt-test. Justify your decision using the principles of hypothesis testing for difference scores.

Sample answer: The researcher should use a one-tailed alternative hypothesis. This is justified because they have a strong theoretical expectation, based on previous literature, that the difference will occur in a specific direction (a decrease in symptom severity). Instead of a general two-tailed alternative hypothesis that the mean difference score is simply not zero (μ00\mu_0 \neq 0), the researcher's alternative hypothesis expects the difference to go in a particular downward direction.

Key points:

  • The researcher should use a one-tailed test.
  • A one-tailed test is appropriate because there is a strong theoretical expectation for the direction of the effect.
  • The alternative hypothesis goes beyond simply stating that the population mean difference is not zero (μ00\mu_0 \neq 0).

Rubric: The response must identify the correct test (one-tailed) and justify it by explaining that the researcher has a specific directional expectation for the treatment effect.

0

1

Updated 2026-05-27

Contributors are:

Who are from:

Tags

KPU

Research Methods in Psychology - 4th American Edition @ KPU

Related