Criticisms of Instinct Theory of Motivation
The instinct theory of motivation faced significant criticism. A major point of contention was the lack of consensus among early psychologists, like William James and his contemporaries, on what exactly constituted an instinct, leading to differing lists of proposed instincts. The theory was further challenged by the undeniable role of learning in shaping human behavior. Experiments in the early 1900s, such as Watson's work with "Little Albert," demonstrated that behaviors once considered instinctive could be the result of associative learning.
0
1
Contributors are:
Who are from:
Tags
Psychology
Social Science
Empirical Science
Science
Online Communities
CSCW (Computer-supported cooperative work)
Computing Sciences
Ch.6 Learning - Psychology @ OpenStax
Psychology @ OpenStax
OpenStax
Ch.9 Lifespan Development - Psychology @ OpenStax
Ch.10 Emotion and Motivation - Psychology @ OpenStax
Introduction to Psychology @ OpenStax Course
OpenStax Psychology (2nd ed.) Textbook
Related
Innate Behavior: Loggerhead Sea Turtle Hatchling's Journey to the Ocean
Comparison of Instincts and Reflexes
Examples of Instinctive Behaviors
Criticisms of Instinct Theory of Motivation
Little Albert's Fear of a Santa Claus Mask
Critical Evaluation of the Little Albert Experiment's Methodology
Criticisms of Instinct Theory of Motivation
Based on the 1920 study conducted by Watson and Rayner, arrange the following events in the correct order to illustrate how the child's emotional response was developed and expanded.
A researcher is investigating how specific fears are acquired in childhood. They observe a child who was previously unafraid of balloons until a balloon popped loudly in their face. Now, the child begins to cry not only when they see balloons, but also when they see round, colorful beach balls.
Applying the logic of the 1920 study conducted by John Watson and Rosalie Rayner, what is the most likely explanation for the child's new reaction to beach balls?
In the 1920 study by Watson and Rayner (shown in the image), the researchers used a specific sequence of events to analyze how emotional responses are developed and expanded. Match each component of their experimental procedure with the specific methodological function it served in their overall analysis of the child's behavior.
Evaluating the 1920 'Little Albert' case study as sufficient evidence to establish universal principles of human emotional development is scientifically sound, provided that the conditioning of the child's fear response was successfully demonstrated.
In the 1920 'Little Albert' case study conducted by John Watson and Rosalie Rayner, how did the researchers teach the young child to fear a white rat?
The 1920 Little Albert experiment demonstrated that a fear of white rats and other furry objects is an unlearned, naturally occurring emotional response in young children.
In 1920, John Watson and Rosalie Rayner repeatedly paired a loud noise with the approach of a white rat to condition a fear response in a young child. This landmark demonstration of how emotional responses can be learned through association is known as the _____ experiment.
Learn After
Examples of Proposed Human Instincts (James's Era)
A psychologist observes that a young child exhibits a strong fear of dogs. An early proponent of the instinct theory of motivation would likely argue this is an innate, unlearned survival mechanism. Which of the following alternative explanations for the child's behavior best illustrates a primary criticism of the instinct theory?