Based on the provided scenario, evaluate the soundness of the manager's decision-making process. Justify your conclusion by explaining the potential strengths and weaknesses of this approach.

Evaluating a Leadership Approach

A follower's degree of extroversion is one characteristic studied in relation to leadership style. Previous research suggested that highly extroverted individuals would need more interaction with their leaders to function well, but other research suggests this may not necessarily be the case and that other factors may be at work.

Google

New York University

Followership research emphasizes that people differ as individuals, so there probably is no single best leadership-follower dynamic. Examples of follower differences include how people respond to criticism and whether they prefer more or less structure.

Characteristics of Followers

Spielman, R. M., Jenkins, W. J., & Lovett, M. D. (2020, April 22). Psychology (2nd ed.). OpenStax. https://openstax.org/books/psychology-2e/pages/1-introduction

OpenStax Psychology (2nd ed.) Textbook

Follower Extroversion and Leadership Interaction

A follower's individual need for growth is a key characteristic influencing the leader-follower dynamic. Followers with a strong desire for organizational growth and learning tend to respond positively to leaders who offer developmental opportunities. Conversely, followers with a low need for growth may become dissatisfied if a leader pushes them toward development, as they might perceive it as being forced or as a sign of their underachievement.

Followers' Need for Growth

An employee's need for leadership is an important part of the leader-follower relationship. More autonomous employees may respond poorly to leaders who provide a lot of structure and rigid processes, which can reduce the quality of the leader-follower relationship. Employees with a high need for leadership tend to have better relationships with leaders when their work environment is well structured, has clear responsibilities, and has little ambiguity. These followers often work best when they can perform within provided guidelines and when the leader sets a clear path forward with little need for deviation.

Followers' Need for Leadership

Based on the case study below, evaluate the manager's leadership approach. Explain the most likely reason for the team member's change in behavior by analyzing the interaction between the leader's style and the follower's probable characteristics.

Analyzing a Leader-Follower Mismatch

Analyze the team dynamics described in the case study. Based on the individual characteristics of the two employees, explain why the manager's leadership approach is effective for one employee but is causing friction with the other.

Learn Before

Related

Learn After