Concept

Comparing effects of different writing activities on reading comprehension: A meta-analysis - Discussion

RQ1: effectiveness of writing on reading comprehension

  • Did not find evidence that one type of writing exercise was more effective than the others in terms of reading comprehension outcomes among summaries, questions, note-taking, and extended writing
  • Meta-analyses of the comparisons could be underpowered because at most 7 studies were considered for each comparison group

RQ2: effectiveness based on outcome measures

  • Statistically significant effect sizes for free recall for summary vs. question comparison
  • No statistically significant effect sizes for free recall in questions vs. notes or questions vs. essay writing
  • Free recall relies on studies recalling main ideas, which is most closely aligned with summaries more so than notes or questions on specific details

0

1

Updated 2021-06-19

Tags

Psychology

Social Science

Empirical Science

Science